I feel like the biggest problem with ret dps right now is AoW. Personally, I've noticed that the largest swings in my dps come from AoW procs. With out them its dismal, with them its competitive.
Theres something not right about that, I'm alright with the 'randomness' that is Divine Purpose, but far to much damage comes from AoW, its just seems like poor design to put so much reliance on something so random.
I guess the discussion I'd like to start is, what do you think is the biggest flaw in ret dps? Or, do you think its fine as it is now? Or are there so many little things wrong that it can not simply be 'bandaged'?
I'd suggest you move on over to this thread. Also, in the future, please refrain from making threads when your questions/opinions/cupcakes may be suited for a thread that already exists.