Wait, so youre saying bats that are made out of stone CANT be skinned???? Wow, you sir should be a politician.
It's really not that dramatic, I was level 80 when I was mining during the first week (pre-nerf) in Twilight Highlands and per lap there would be maybe 2-3 problematic nodes at most. Might be different for herbalism though.
Good thing I got all the Cata LW patterns before the nerf. Was obvious that they would do it eventually tbh.
I personally have 1 skinner 1 miner and a herb. My skinner is fully decked 85 dps and can kill mobs very fast. My herb is level 81 and my miner is 84. I have tested this out. I gained 100 skins in 1 hour of skinning so 5 stacks. I herbs for one hour and got 12 stacks of herbs although was a druid herb so never had to fight a mob. Then i mined for 1 hour and ended up with 200 ore 10 stacks.
This weekend ill try 2 hours of each and see what numbers i get.
The problem i found with Skinning is that i don't have anywhere to skin on my hunter anymore, I'm trying to get my LW up but i can't find any quest zone that actually have mobs that you can skin as you go along.. Take Hellfire, Borean as example, they all had great mobs for killing and skinning, but now.. We got nothing.. And with the removal of the bats, where on earth am i gonna farm?
Lol I was so disappointed when I found out I couldn't skin the bats anymore! At 5am I was skinning, log out, log back in around 5pm and can't skin them anymore! It was way OP though so I dont blame Blizz. I would agree that there are not that many mobs to skin in new zones!
Some good places I found:
Hyjal- Charbringers along the westernmost road that runs north and south
Vashj'ir- Aye, the crabs in the very first starting zone. Haven't done any other quests there yet.
Deepholm- Still my favorite minus the bats. Farm the basilisks in the whitish part of the map (can't remember the name) they respawn by the time it's time to do another lap and drop guaranteed leather, not scraps. Also, the quest area where the slate dragons fall from the sky at half health and you have to kill them, this is a good place bc there are usually lots of people doing this quest at any given time and you can just run along behind and collect after them. Of course it is nice to throw in a helpful dot every now and then
Twilight Highlands- The area towards the last questing part where you have to kill drakes and dragonkin. These have a chance to drop scales as well I think.
On the subject of Pristine Hides, I agree! I got 2 the very first night of Cata release and have yet to see another! Thankfully, you can trade in 10 heavy leather for 1 hide in TH.