Gemcrafter Extrodinare?

[Eiiga]

Has anyone else had any problems with this or know anything about it? I've cut quite a few cata blue gems since release and none have counted, but someone in my guild with about 345 jewelcrafting cut a blue BC gem and it did count. I've tried various different colors and stat gems with no luck.

[Biaxident]

Honored reputation with your guild may be required.

[Lucetia]

Has anyone else had any problems with this or know anything about it? I've cut quite a few cata blue gems since release and none have counted, but someone in my guild with about 345 jewelcrafting cut a blue BC gem and it did count. I've tried various different colors and stat gems with no luck.

I talked to a GM about this. They said the achievement is currently bugged and they are working on it.

Right now if a jewelcrafter cuts a rare gem or above (Cataclysm) it does not count. The only thing I have found that counts is if an alchemist transmutes a gem. The GM said that is not the case as it specifically states "cuts".

[Agape]

I've noticed this as well. Luckily the WotLK and TBC rare gems are sold on the AH for close to what they vendor for on my server - so I just buy them up and cut them for the achievement.