Do you think blinded by acid is a fair punishment?

[Penric]

http://us.cnn.com/2011/WORLD/meast/0...ex.html?hpt=T2


A man who threw acid in a womans face has now the same fate, the acid droplets to the eyes will be administered by the lady herself.

Do you think this punishment is just and fair?

[Goldrinn]

Oh, of course. I was about to come in here and say "What the hell? Of course not.", but if it's to give him a taste of his own medicine.. sure, what the hell. I say burn his whole damn face off.

I mean, I know two wrongs don't make a right, but if someone threw acid in my face, I'd definitely want to do the same to them.

[Dodrin]

It's a bit morbid, but it is a direct reciprocation. So I would say yes, it's as "fair" as it's going to get.

[Deleted]

No, waste of good acid, just throw him down a pit to starve, much more efficient

[Elixor]

It´s only few drops? That´s nothing compared to getting slammed with it.

Edit: Just read that he threw a fucking bucket of acid on her. He should atleast get a cup of acid on him.

[Detheavn]

"It is unbelievable that the Iranian authorities would consider implementing such a punishment," said Hassiba Hadj Sahraoui, an Amnesty International deputy director.

It's ubelievable that a person can do something like that and expect walk away. He threw a bucket of acid in the woman's face. Indeed, he should deserve the same. Death would be a blessing.

[Synithin]

Tbh lifetime in an isolation cell would be a better punishment. Just 4 white wall and a madress for the rest of his life :P

[Dodrin]

No.

But the usual suspects will probably sprout some "let the punishment fit the crime" nonsense.

And why shouldn't the punishment fit the crime? It makes more sense than "Man killed man, send him to jail for x years".

[Poppasan]

Ohai, I just burned your skin and you have to go through numerous surgeries, and I only got a warning.
/sarcasm.

[Wilian]

I have always been in favour of eye for an eye. It's nice little pre-emptive system.

[Spl4sh3r]

Why not get a transplant, take his eyes and put them in her?

[Detheavn]

Why not get a transplant, take his eyes and put them in her?

And the rest of her face? :|

[Deleted]

Do you think this punishment is just and fair?

Yes. I do.

And Amnesty International should go fuck themselves and stop interfering into laws and other stuff.

Tell you the newest snippets of what they did here. We have a gypsy problem, these people who squat on goverment land, build their houses without permits and don't give a fuck about the law, then demand social support, they cheat and steal and continually whine how they as a minority are neglected and segregated. They also don't send their children to schools, they don't work, don't pay taxes or bills either.

Now comes Amnesty International with it's study that 21 of those gypsy places don't have access to running water and demands something be done about it.

<snip>

Mod Warning: Everyone has their opinion, but watch the language. No need to swear.
Edit: Thanks for reminding me. I ussually delete the post but sometimes, sometimes that button to post just sort of auto-presses itself.

[BatteredRose]

It's ubelievable that a person can do something like that and expect walk away. He threw a bucket of acid in the woman's face. Indeed, he should deserve the same. Death would be a blessing.

Couldn't have said it better myself.

[Elixor]

http://www.google.fi/imgres?imgurl=h...ed=0CC8Q9QEwBA

I think that´s her.

[Deleted]

Just execute him. He sounds insane anyway.

[Wilian]

It is also nice to know that men are punished accordinly to their actions in Iran, in the light of all the stonings done to the women.

[pateuvasiliu]

Any1 considering that the guy may be mad?

If so,how can you make a mad person go through torture?

[Deleted]

I have no right to interfer with this, neither does anyone else.


bleeding hearts always ruining everything.

[Porimlys]

No. It may seem cliche but...

"An eye for an eye makes the whole world blind"

I think theres truth in that.