10Man, H Beth or H Baleroc next?

[Deleted]

Hi there, I would class us as a "good" 10man guild that was set up just before firelands release, unfortunately weve been held back in progress by only having max 6hours / week raiding time for the last 6 weeks but are now able to get together 12hours a week as weve boosted the roster size a bit.

Our current progress is 4/7 HC, we killed H Shan (1hour progress to kill) -> H Domo (3hours progress to kill) -> H Alysrazor (5hours progress to kill) -> H Rhyolith (we 1shot this on the progress try last night).

We "have" the DPS that could do Baleroc but I believe we would only just be beating the enrage, with probably an average DPS of ~27k (raid is currently average iL ~375), we also have pretty much the perfect setup available for healing+soaking this fight. Equally we have a "perfect" setup for Beth'tilac and we have INCREDIBLY good healers, imo quite a bit better than our DPS are.

So what should we go for next week? H Beth or H Baleroc and approximately how long in progress do you think each would take us?

Huge thanks in advance.

[Deleted]

My guild recently downsized to 10 man after facing major issues as a 25 man guild. We managed to down 3/7 as a 25 man guild and only two raid-days after downsizing we had 6/7 Heroic. We went in last Wednesday after the Beth'tilac HC nerfs and LITERALLY 2-shot her. I don't know how big of a nerf she was dealt but it was insanely easy for us, so I'd say go Beth'tilac if you have a hunter available (completely trivializes the spiderling/soaking part of the fight).

As for Baleroc it is also extremely easy if you have a shadowpriest and a decent healer-setup.

You'll face succes regardless of which boss you decide to pull - they are both jokes imo.

[Deleted]

My guild recently downsized to 10 man after facing major issues as a 25 man guild. We managed to down 3/7 as a 25 man guild and only two raid-days after downsizing we had 6/7 Heroic. We went in last Wednesday after the Beth'tilac HC nerfs and LITERALLY 2-shot her. I don't know how big of a nerf she was dealt but it was insanely easy for us, so I'd say go Beth'tilac if you have a hunter available (completely trivializes the spiderling/soaking part of the fight).

As for Baleroc it is also extremely easy if you have a shadowpriest and a decent healer-setup.

You'll face succes regardless of which boss you decide to pull - they are both jokes imo.

We have 2 hunters so beth is NP setupwise, we have 1 spriest, 1 dpriest, 1 HPala so baleroc would be NP in terms of setup too :P

Thanks for the tips

[timoseewho]

From your setup, either of those fights would sound easy, do you happen to have a pPapaldin too?

[Deleted]

From your setup, either of those fights would sound easy, do you happen to have a pPapaldin too?

Yes, just to add to the lols of setup our main tank is prot paladin.

[Deleted]

I would say Beth'ilac from my expirience.