Originally Posted by
Lyese
A) Stop quoting Ret 3.0. DivStorm doing Holy damage lasted about 10 hours on live, and the initial round of nerfs were hotfixed in 2 weeks later. That also wasn't Ret being "on-par" with everyone else, it was Ret being stupidly massively op. We want balance, not to be overpowered.
B) With the new spec system, it's EASY to buff ret without overbuffing prot. That's why they implemented the system in the first place, so they have more knobs to turn. What you're giving is a sad excuse for the shitty design behind the spec, which honestly, went against their design goal (Blizz went on record to say they want Ret to have less burst and more ramp up with steadier damage prior to Cata.) since our only decent option is burst.
C) "Tons of FOTM rerollers" didn't hurt when everyone rolled MS/Druid in S2-4, RMP throughout most of arena, Warlocks when SL/SL was viable, etc etc. Not even during the short lived period when Ret was OP was representation adversely affected, since it was a short window (in fact, gladiator titles had been handed out beforehand iirc because Lavabeard kept making posts to end the season before the patch).