Originally Posted by
Jeffari
1) Paladins gain mana back from judging so for someone who is so conscious about his mana, he barely made use of judge during that fight. He did a total of 24 judges over the course of 6 mins 45 seconds. Judge has a 8 second cooldown but lets say you get 1 off every 10 seconds, that's a total 40 judges that should be going off. Judgement gives us 15% of our base mana back so (23422x0.15) = 3513.3 mana back per judge. He missed a total of 16 Judge's which more or less resulted in 56,212 mana he did not make use of.
2) He didn't use any potions. I always pre pot with a volcanic potion when healing and use a concentration potion during fight.
-The logs say he never used avenging wrath, divine favor or divine plea???? Two HUGE paladin buffs that assist with healing. Using both topped with holy radiance with allow some big healing. Every 5% of haste we get, holy radiance gets another tick of healing. With divine favor up (20% haste buff) we'd get an extra 4 ticks which is beyond good for this fight.
3) A few things that need tweaking but I think if he has the drive to do some research on his own you should keep him. There are a lot of haste pieces he's missing, along with 4 piece.