So using Landsouls Spreadsheet Beta 3, during different points in my gear progression I've found one to be better than the other; mainly Cloudburst Cloak of the Earthshaker from Al'Akir. However now Bladed Flamewrath Cloak has become better for me as I have reached full Best in Slot besides the second Sulfuras.
While trying to figure that out, I also decided to see about how 1/2BV differed really from 2/2BV, and using the Increased Death Wish value 2s before Pull vs 4s past pull.
Was wondering if anyone else reached the same conclusion or found differences. This might be a little hard to follow my thinking but try your best
Sinnermighty's Headache for Tier 12
- Comparing 1/2 Booming Voice vs. 2/2 Booming Voice
- 1700 Pre-Combat Mastery, Deathwish 2s before Pull vs 1260 Pre-Combat Mastery, Deathwish 4s after pull
- Cloudburst Cloak of the Earthshaker vs. Bladed Flamewrath Cloak
Used Landsouls Spreadsheet Beta 3
Gearsets Used
Bladed Flamewrath Cloak Set: http://chardev.org/?profile=263434
Cloudburst Cloak Set: http://chardev.org/?profile=263432
Reforging Changes to get to Bladed Set from Cloudburst Set:
Bladed: Haste -> Crit
Rep Ring: Hit -> Exp
Alys Ring: Expertise -> Crit
Giantslicer: Exp -> Crit
Reforging Changes to get to Cloudburst Set from Bladed Set:
Cloudburst: -> Hit->Exp
Alys: Haste->Crit
Rep Ring: No Reforge
Giantslicer: Hit->Crit
Settings:
Full Buffs
Full Debuffs
5min 35s Fight
Use Heroic Leap on CD
No Forced Weapon Sync
Flask - Titanic Strength
Food: +90STR
Boss: Armor 11978
---------------------------------------------------------
1700 Pre-Combat Mastery -2 Death Wish
Bladed Setup
37896.7176 DPS
37887.6782 DPS with 2/2 BV = 9.0394 DPS loss
Cloudburst Setup
37893.7811 DPS
37884.7117 DPS with 2/2 BV = 9.0694 DPS loss
+2.9365 DPS to go Bladed 1/2 BV vs. Cloudburst
--------------------------
1260 Pre-Combat Mastery 4s Death Wish
Bladed Setup
37629.8124 DPS
37615.6916 DPS with 2/2 BV = 14.1208 DPS loss
Cloudburst Setup
37626.5158 DPS
37612.4836 DPS with 2/2 BV = 14.0322 DPS loss
+3.2966 DPS to go Bladed 1/2 BV vs. Cloudburst
----------------------------------------------------
1700 Pre-Combat Mastery -2s DW vs 1260 Pre-Combat Mastery 4s Death Wish
Bladed Cloak: +266.9052 DPS w/1700 Mastery vs 1260
.......with 2/2BV +271.9866 DPS w/1700 Mastery vs 1260
Cloudburst Cloak: +267.2653 DPS w/1700 Mastery vs 1260
.....with 2/2BV +272.2281 DPS w/1700 Mastery vs 1260
----------------------------------------------------------
Conclusion: Start using Pre-Pull Mastery Deathwish Increase with Bladed Setup with 1/2 BV for Maximum DPS in BiS Gear.
Next on my list: Cinch of the Flaming Ember vs Uncrushable Belt of Fury & Apparatus of Khaz'goroth vs Heart of Rage (Both might be inter-related)