Originally Posted by
anthemm
The statement that your Feral should be doing 75-80k depends on how fast the boss dies.
Looking over your log, the reason why you wiped on Garalon is because of those PuGs you say you got. Two healing the fight makes the DPS requirement pretty easy. And no, a Feral should not be topping on Garalon. Ever. Feral energy regen is slow, and you simply cannot dump damage into Garalon's legs whenever you feel like it. As practically any other DPS spec, it's pretty easy to frontload tons of damage into those legs since most DPS specs don't use energy. Also, Feral has a high skill cap, so trying to maximize your DPS gets pretty challenging.
However, your Feral could be doing more damage. I'm less geared than he is, and I do 100k DPS on Garalon, and I am by no means that skilled. To make Garalon really easy, you can get a Combat Rogue to trivialize the fight, or a Warrior using Sweeping Strikes, unless Blizz has already implemented the nerf that no longer makes them do double damage to the boss when they hit Garalon's legs.