What would you rate each x-pac 1-10???

[Shinz]

Vanilla gets a 10/10 for being such an epic game for the year it was released. for me it was a mind blowing game.
BC gets a 10/10 also for improving on the game and for keeping it epic.
Wrath gets a 9/10 for being a great game took the environment to a whole new level and gave a truly one of a kind experience.
Cata gets a 8/10 for taking so much time to revamp the old world and to add new zones. Only thing lacking was the fact that it felt like it was smaller than before because the new zones were hidden areas in the old world. Most of the work got spent on 1-60 IMO.
Mists gets a 9/10 for adding so much and for taking the time to put in such beautiful landscapes that we had to experience on the ground and it was also breathtaking from the air.
So overall wow with the xpacs gets a 9.5/10 in my books it is a truly phenomenal game that not only allows communication with others but allows them to experience the world together as a team like a true MMO should. The amount of work they put into the game is unparalleled and it also allows players to choose their own play style and leveling paths. The players truly have control over their destiny.

[Colonel Sandor]

I'm gonna break the rules and do 1-5 since 1-10 has a lot of useless numbers.

Vanilla: 5/5 (Good for the time)
BC: 4/5
Wotlk: 4/5
Cata: 2/5
MoP: 5/5

[--Code--]

BC: 9/10
Wrath of the Lich King 8/10
Cata: 7/10
MoP: 1/10
The game went from Demons/Infernos to Undead/Death to Huge ass dragons/lots of fire, to Pandas, flowers, monkeys, and fish people.

[cuafpr]

Vanilla = 7/10 - to much grinding for raid mats and horrid stats on gear
B/C = 4/10 - being deployed for the first six months i can say attunments can suck it when ur forced to play catch up.
LK = 10/10 - was perfect imo, great lore, ICC is my fav raid and didn't mind running it for a year (inronically ulduar was my least fav in the xpac felt out of place)
Cata = 5/10 - felt to much like a puzzle that wasn't put together right
MoP = 7/10 - not alt friendly enough and daily over kill. If counted the addition of the gear in the store i'd prob drop it to 0/10.

[NewportsDentarg]

Vanilla = 9/10
B/C = 9/10
LK = 9/10
Cata = -/10 (Stopped playing when this was live)
MoP = 8/10

[killidan]

Vanilla = 8/10
B/C = 9/10
LK = 7/10
Cata = 4/10
MoP = 2/10

[Cyno]

Started two months after the release of TBC so...

TBC: 10/10
WotLK: 8/10
Cata: 3/10
MoP: 5/10

[reef]

wotlk 9, cata 8, mop 2.

[Eon Drache]

basing this on the time of release or quality now?

If only based on what we know now?

Vanilla: 2 of 10
Burning Crusade: 4 of 10
Wrath of the Lich King: 8 of 10
Cataclysm: 6 of 10
Mists of Pandaria: 5 of 10

[Viradiance]

I don't subscribe to that "BC WAS THE BEST EVER" nostalgia circlejerk. In many ways, it was reaaaaaally shitty.

Vanilla -- Didn't play, no honest opinion.
Burning Crusade -- 5 / 10
Wrath of the Lich King -- 9 / 10
Cataclysm -- 7 / 10
Pandaland -- 8/10

[Deleted]

Vanilla = 8/10 (it was enjoyable, nothing I'd ever seen before, I was like 12/13 so that factors into it)
B/C = 10/10 (most enjoyable time I've had in all aspects of the game)
LK = 7.5/10 (mostly great, ICC patch got boring, best state PvPs been was S7/S8 most people don't debate this)
Cata = 4/10 (barely any content if you weren't leveling, boring, terrible mechanics changes which have ruined some of the fun MoP could have been)
MoP = 6/10 (better than Cata, Blizz clearly put more effort in that Cata, thing are looking up for PvP with Holinka, but still recovering from the terrible Cata changes)

[Shaqur]

Vanilla 1/10 -- by today standards
BC 8/10
Wotlk 10/10
Cata 7/10
MoP 8/10

[Deleted]

I don't subscribe to that "BC WAS THE BEST EVER" nostalgia circlejerk. In many ways, it was reaaaaaally shitty.

If you only started playing in BC thats probably why you didn't enjoy it.

[Chickat]

Im going to rate them for how good they were at the time.

Vanilla 9
TBC 9
Wrath 9
Cata 7
MoP 8

Now i will rate them as if they were all released today

Vanilla 5
TBC 6
Cata 7
Wrath 8.5
MoP 8

Now i will rate the xpacs based on fun had.

Vanilla 8
TBC 7
Wrath 10
Cata 6
MoP 8

[Skez]

Vanilla - 7/10
TBC - 10/10
WotLK - 8/10
Cata - 5/10
Panda - 3/10

[Elyara]

Vanilla 8.5/10
BC 9/10
Wotlk 7/10
Cata 8/10
MoP 9/10

[Lime]

Vanilla = 5/10
TBC = 7.5/10
WotLK = 8/10
Cata = 7/10
MoP = 9/10

[Kegler]

Vanilla - 9
Burning Crusade - 8
WotLK - 10
Cataclysm - 8
MoP - 9

[Sandrox]

Vanilla - 7
BC - 8
Wrath - 9
Cata - 5
MoP - 7

[~Valen~]

Did not play during Vanilla...

TBC = 7/10
WotLK = 9/10
Cata = 5/10 (If not for the RBGs, it would have been around 2-3)
MoP = 8.5/10

Well, I loved WotLK because I loved the raid and the atmosphere. I did not find the community to be as horrible as some people make it to be.

TBC was nice and all, but certainly didn't have the vibe of WotLK. Karazhan was very impressive to say the least.

During Cata, I loved the fun involved in RBGs, but being in Orgrimmar all the time was well BORING!

MoP has a great art style, music and I really like the story involved. The diversity is very pleasing (well not dailies of course) and the amount of things available have lured me out of Orgrimmar every now and then. Only reason I do not rate in as 9/9.5 is because I despise the path they have chosen to follow for certain classes, including Holy Paladins.