Ok, brilliant with the feedback and all, keep it going guys!!
Here's my thoughts on the matter.
LOVE active mitigation, truly brilliant idea!
Did it feel fluid though through MoP? Hell no!
Was after ToT that the item levels allowed us to kinda not feel clunky with our rotation and actually started to feel that active mitigation started to work for us.
So, is it great now? Not for me.
I feel like the fact we have a rotation is wrong. Prot = tank. Tank = Hold threat, Stay alive. Sure the dps aspect is fun and useful to our raiding teams, but is it our job? Should it be?
*snip*
As for the 100 lvl talents, stance dancing would be a great tool, but not with the seals in GCD as been said before!! Please put the seals off GCD!!! It's just wrong....
As for the Seraphim one...I just think that 30secs for 5 HP will add more clunky factor to our "rotation"....meh. 1min CD on that might actually feel a bit more productive, but I still think you are heading in the wrong way with Pala design in WoD. We need to feel more like rewarded by playing smart, and reduce our inc damage and avoid stuff that been pushed to do more dps. My opinion.
As for the holy shield talent, I don't know, I need to see it play to say more, but from what I read, I think it's very promising for the direction the protection paladin should be headed. But on it's own, and as it stands, it doesn't feel like a great reward for a 100 talent choice. Could be wrong though...as I said, I need to see it play..