Oh, Im going to just re-use my post from similar topic on GD forum ^^
Hey guys!
Since I am a CM geek, I've read this topic, and just wanted to share a few words as a person which is actually fighting for those titles.
For once, my group have managed to acquire them at the very begining, and after few months we lost them. No biggie, we can always get them back. And we were about to, just talking with people and setting up for a few (dozen?) runs to retake them. Times on our server aren't that tough, so why not. Some of those people have only stayed in MoP for so long, after clearing 14/14hc, just to enjoy that competition of running against other groups, to see who - in the end - will be best and aquires those titles. Sounds like fun to me, even if only for those elite groups, but hey - its not like people are complaining that Garrosh hc is too elite, right?
Now, some of you are trying to tell me, that it is just vile for a few reasons.
1. Another group can beat you in all on the very last day, and get them from you. Well, yea, I guess thats what competition is all about. If you are not carefull, same thing can happen in arena brackets with your glad title. Last day you can just get bounced from top, and you end with nothing. Thats is why those groups are sitting now in CMs, getting best times they can think of - and if someone beats them - its only fair to approve their superiority. After announcement, that titles are being removed - carrot is gone, so who would want to just improve? Got FoSes, im done. And, which is important as well, if times are decent, it is impossible to retake them all in 1 day (or even a week) without a long practise period. Current world record in SH is 2:58, on good servers around 3:30-3:40. Good luck one shotting that.
2. CMs r1 would be sold around for titles - Well, boo freakin' hoo, so what? Wake up, every day dozens of players are getting boosted through CM golds, 14/14hcs, arenas and so on. If server is any good, then it is not possible to get those FoSes with a customer. You can trust this guy - I have over 600 CMs completed on my priest only. On the other hand - boosting someone on some dead realm? Fine, why not, if any 'native' 5 man group will gather to do them, its theirs. Not even 1 trully boosting group will be able to maintain those r1 with a customer, in case any other group wants to get them. Becouse after they get beaten, they would have to get back there. And again. And again. Up to a point where you are just not able to do it with a customer - unless you practise with him a lot - but I've never heard of such a long-term boosting agreement :P
3. Those titles can only be aquired only by certain classes - ok, thats true in most cases - so how does it work, when each season in a PvP ladder one setup is just taking it all - and noone is complaining on a similiar level? If you really want those titles (which are character specific btw), you can just roll an alt. It all depends on your commitment. Besides, I've seen some seriously strange setups on various servers, that just blew my mind - and their times were actually good. Like I said - its all about how serious you are about your efforts and how imaginative you can be - to come up with new tactics which will let you be that few seconds faster each try.
And Im happy to answer to more. In my opinion this decision from Blizz only took a huge piece of fun lots of people could have while fighting over those titles, myself included. Ah well, maybe they will change their mind in a few days - after all that CM blog looks just so poorly written..
Cheers, thanks for reading, take care.
Quid - EU-Stormscale