I don't really care about the pw:w gear, mainly because I'm a filthy casual and as long as there are other gear available that don't require the attunement I'm ok with it. Read your post in the other thread and bought a bunch of cheap NT quality 60/61 gear off the AH for my cleric. (She's 60, but I'm not done with SL zones and since it's my first time through there I wanted to see the storylines.) It's just lame to put it on leveling quest rewards, and the whole thing reminds me somewhat of SWTOR's artifact authorization unlocks and quest reward limits. It's bad juju in general to mess with players' rewards.
What I find problematic is gating the earrings slots behind a paywall. If /4 chat is to be believed and those earrings are in <60 loot tables, what is Trion saying to newer players? "Welcome! No tricks, no traps. Oh by the way those L20 earrings you just got? We want $25 for you to equip them now. Or wait until L60+ and grind out 100k VS to wear them." I'm sure that will go over well with your new customers. It doesn't matter that we all have leveled without the earrings, this is the new "now" and players have an expectation of equipping class appropriate loot that they've acquired.
I get that they want to be paid for their work and I'd like to see them get paid for their work, but this is a very inelegant solution. I really would have rather they charge everybody $30-40 base for access to the new content, for the new souls and have none of this bullshit. Yes, it would have gone against "completely free to play" but at least it's upfront without having to put in some exasperated eyeroll inducing pain points just to get people to grudgingly pay you $25. Only other solution they can do is sell these things for credits, but if that's to happen at all my guess is it will be towards the end of this expansion cycle where they won't be cannibalizing the collectors edition sales. I'll likely pay $25 later mainly because I just don't have that kind of time to grind out all those VS. But like you, I'm torn with not wanting to encourage more of this kind of behavior.