Rate The Rogue Above You.

[Deleted]

Chevelle
I can't really judge your PvE gear if i cannot see it
Considering your 3v3 rating it feels like you should know what you're doing, but i don't really agree with your reforging and perhaps some gemming. Some items you just haven't reforged, i don't know if it's due to slacking or if you don't want the items reforged, but you want some spell penetration so that your poisons wont be resisted. You should also get that last 0,5% hit chance that you have over the 5% cap. After that you want to reforge into crit and not expertise. Checking this chart should help you with your reforging: Agility > Resilience > 195 Spell Penetration > 5% Melee Hit > Crit > Haste > Mastery > Expertise. Can't say anything about your spec, it looks good.

You seem to know your class well but you need to put down more time into your gear, will give you a 6/10 since you haven't reforged properly.

Sorry but i cant post any links yet, but my name is Krajzee on Kazzak (EU). Would be great if you could just search for me instead . (Just transferred server so i am currently without a guild nor an arena team)

[Deleted]

Well you are at pvp gear, and i sux bad at pvp. The only thing i could say is that you lack the parachutes, really usefull in arathi basin :P

My rogue is at my syg, be gentle!

Your spec looks nice except that i would not put talents in improved recuperate for PvE, you shouldn't want to use Combo Points for it and if you want damage reduction you can most often use Feint. I'd put them in Improved Sprint instead since that may come in handy in some fights.
When it comes to your reforging you shouldn't reforge more hit, you have enough as it is. You want to have at least 26/26 expertise and after that you want haste, haste and even more haste. You should fill out that last glyph slot with something as well, Glyph of Poisons perhaps . Other than that it looks good, 7/10

Would be lovely if someone could comment on me as well, name Krajzee on Kazzak (EU)

[Matutin]

Your spec looks nice except that i would not put talents in improved recuperate for PvE, you shouldn't want to use Combo Points for it and if you want damage reduction you can most often use Feint. I'd put them in Improved Sprint instead since that may come in handy in some fights.
When it comes to your reforging you shouldn't reforge more hit, you have enough as it is. You want to have at least 26/26 expertise and after that you want haste, haste and even more haste. You should fill out that last glyph slot with something as well, Glyph of Poisons perhaps . Other than that it looks good, 7/10

Would be lovely if someone could comment on me as well, name Krajzee on Kazzak (EU)

Well, i use a lot of recup on some FL fights, beth and ryo for example, also the dmg reduction does stack with feint, it is really usefull on some fights. Also, this may be needed for next patch, on fights like the big dragon before DW (cant remember the name), for the big aoe bad spell that you have to go to other dimension that i also cant remember the name :P

Well, spell hit cap > crit for t12, so i'm following what mr robot says :P

and yes, totally forgot about that last glyph, ty!

[Deleted]

As you realized, the empty glyph slot. Also haste on gloves instead of mastery. Only took a quick glance, but if you aren't using Shadowcraft to optimize your rogue, you should start doing so.

http://eu.battle.net/wow/en/characte...teeth/advanced

[Deleted]

Well, i use a lot of recup on some FL fights, beth and ryo for example, also the dmg reduction does stack with feint, it is really usefull on some fights. Also, this may be needed for next patch, on fights like the big dragon before DW (cant remember the name), for the big aoe bad spell that you have to go to other dimension that i also cant remember the name :P

Well, spell hit cap > crit for t12, so i'm following what mr robot says :P

and yes, totally forgot about that last glyph, ty!

I go by what noxxic.com says. They say that as an assasination rogue you want the spell hit cap so that you can deal more damage with your poisons since that is the main source of damage as an assasination rogue, but that's not the case as combat. As combat the main source of damage is melee hits through SaD, Sinister strike and eviscerate. Haste increases both your attack speed and your energy regeneration. The 17% spell hit cap is still important, but haste is imo still better. Also haste is a funnier stat to stack since you get to do more stuff!

[KeirAdish]

My OH and shoulders aren't enchanted because I don't have rep for shoulders and I'm not putting landslide on such a crappy OH... XD

http://us.battle.net/wow/en/characte...C3%A1/advanced

[Mythius101]

us.battle.net/wow/en/character/shattered-hand/Mythius/advanced

any recommendations?

sorry i can't post links yet :|

[Deleted]

Baremyteeth:

Nothing to comment on here, looks all good! 10/10

[Matutin]

As you realized, the empty glyph slot. Also haste on gloves instead of mastery. Only took a quick glance, but if you aren't using Shadowcraft to optimize your rogue, you should start doing so.

http://eu.battle.net/wow/en/characte...teeth/advanced

Yes, im aware about both my missing glypth (thanks to Krajzee :P) and my gloves enchant. I'll get my t12 ones this week so i wont change the chant till then.

Bout your char, didnt found anything wrong, maybe get an 20 agi+20 haste for your offhand, i think that 30agi+20haste>40agi

EDIT: forgot you say, you are a cute little gnome (this make me want to kill you)

I go by what noxxic.com says. They say that as an assasination rogue you want the spell hit cap so that you can deal more damage with your poisons since that is the main source of damage as an assasination rogue, but that's not the case as combat. As combat the main source of damage is melee hits through SaD, Sinister strike and eviscerate. Haste increases both your attack speed and your energy regeneration. The 17% spell hit cap is still important, but haste is imo still better. Also haste is a funnier stat to stack since you get to do more stuff!

Yes, i try to get as much haste as I can, but when i'm unable to reforge somethign to haste, i usually go with crit > expertise (if not capped) or hit otherwise, since that hit have a greater EP than crit (till spell cap).


Btw, no need to rate me again :P

[Hjalmar]

@ Dolz overall I'd say pretty good. not a big fan of the rag hunter bow but if you weapon swap than meh. super jelly of your offhand though haha. I don't know much about combat (haven't played it since nax) but overall i'd say the gems and reforging look good.

http://us.battle.net/wow/en/characte...Hjalmer/simple

I probably failed and didn't hit "last page" so disregard everything I said if this is the case

[Naekhrah]

@Hjalmar, little bit reforging wrists crit-> mastery, ring haste-> hit, head haste -> mastery and belt crit -> mastery. And you gain 21dps! Gemming spot on.


http://eu.battle.net/wow/en/characte...aekhrah/simple

[Lilixer]

So..Naekhrah...not much to really say haha. You look fantastic

http://us.battle.net/wow/en/characte...oison/advanced

[Novarx]

So..Naekhrah...not much to really say haha. You look fantastic

http://us.battle.net/wow/en/characte...oison/advanced

Lili, is this possibly a rogue alt? Well anyways, I would first suggest, getting an enchant on that helm of yours, replacing the cloak enchant with the +22 agi to cloak instead of the 50 crit rating. Can you possibly pick up the rep belt from the avenger's of hyjal, it will be a vast increase from the one you have, try reforging the crit on your legs to hit instead of expertise, change the enchant on your boots from mastery to expertise, and the reforge on your ring from haste to expertise. That should get you to expertise cap, and close to spell hit. Another idea is try getting heroic Tia's grace, or even the rep trinket from avenger's if you have the rep. Change the reforge on your mace from mastery to hit as well. Good luck, everything seems to be in working order, a few tweeks here and there and you'll notice a difference!
http://us.battle.net/wow/en/characte.../Novarx/simple

[Deleted]

So..Naekhrah...not much to really say haha. You look fantastic

http://us.battle.net/wow/en/characte...oison/advanced

Woah! fantastic name you've got. Really. You've got some nice PvE gear in my opinion and you look awesome stats are all okay so in my opinion it's a 4/5 ( Not giving 5/5 since that's full Firelands hc )

Edit: Oooh we've got a fast one

Lili, is this possibly a rogue alt? Well anyways, I would first suggest, getting an enchant on that helm of yours, replacing the cloak enchant with the +22 agi to cloak instead of the 50 crit rating. Can you possibly pick up the rep belt from the avenger's of hyjal, it will be a vast increase from the one you have, try reforging the crit on your legs to hit instead of expertise, change the enchant on your boots from mastery to expertise, and the reforge on your ring from haste to expertise. That should get you to expertise cap, and close to spell hit. Another idea is try getting heroic Tia's grace, or even the rep trinket from avenger's if you have the rep. Change the reforge on your mace from mastery to hit as well. Good luck, everything seems to be in working order, a few tweeks here and there and you'll notice a difference!
http://us.battle.net/wow/en/characte.../Novarx/simple

Incredible geared, Nice achievements / feats of strength. You've got quite some RBG rating. Nice. I'd say a 4/5 for you too

[Lilixer]

Lili, is this possibly a rogue alt? Well anyways, I would first suggest, getting an enchant on that helm of yours, replacing the cloak enchant with the +22 agi to cloak instead of the 50 crit rating. Can you possibly pick up the rep belt from the avenger's of hyjal, it will be a vast increase from the one you have, try reforging the crit on your legs to hit instead of expertise, change the enchant on your boots from mastery to expertise, and the reforge on your ring from haste to expertise. That should get you to expertise cap, and close to spell hit. Another idea is try getting heroic Tia's grace, or even the rep trinket from avenger's if you have the rep. Change the reforge on your mace from mastery to hit as well. Good luck, everything seems to be in working order, a few tweeks here and there and you'll notice a difference!
http://us.battle.net/wow/en/characte.../Novarx/simple

Yes Rogue alt I'm a warlock main but have been playing around with my rogue for the last couple of weeks, thanks for the tips Novarx! I'll get right on that in the next couple of days

[KeirAdish]

http://us.battle.net/wow/en/characte...C3%A1/advanced
Ok, updated with new gear.

OH still isn't enchanted because I haven't gotten a better OH and I don't want to put Landslide on a crappy offhand like that.

[JabJack]

http://us.battle.net/wow/en/characte...C3%A1/advanced
Ok, updated with new gear.

OH still isn't enchanted because I haven't gotten a better OH and I don't want to put Landslide on a crappy offhand like that.

No bad for gear def want to run some more zg to try and get oh dagger

http://us.battle.net/wow/en/characte...bverted/simple

[Lumiair]

No bad for gear def want to run some more zg to try and get oh dagger

http://us.battle.net/wow/en/characte...bverted/simple

Man, I'm jealous of your gear. But honestly there isn't much to change other than you could always get the nitro boost on your belt since you're an engineer, always comes in handy (when it works)

http://us.battle.net/wow/en/characte...unåsta/simple

[Deleted]

Liuv on Eredar EU

[Deleted]

Liuv on Eredar EU

You realise you're meant to critique the poster above you, not just post your name right? ¬_¬
I'll do the person you were meant to anyway, seing as you clearly dont have the capacity to understand how the thread works.

http://us.battle.net/wow/en/characte...3%A5sta/simple

Goblin is a plus :3
gear is looking great, I assume you're waiting to replace that helmet with the tier piece for the 4set bonus ?:P
Overall i'd say around an 8/10


Feel free to decimate my rogue, only been 85 for about 10h /played.
Clicky