Rate The Rogue Above You.

[sesom]

Good sirs and ladies of the shadow, direct me in the right direction. What improvements can be made?

http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...+Ring&cn=Sesom

[Turmynator]

^ hey start by finding a better trinket than that needle PoS as mut its worthless since half your dmg is poison dmg and its unaffected by armor pen.

2nd edit* Get expertise cap aka 26 just replace 1 40 ap gem by an exp gem and it should make it and you are a lil bit short on hit get that up there asap

3rd edit in 4 minute im retarded and in pvp gear rofl .. let me try to fix that


http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...huzad&cn=Lukyy


this be me i know i got some armor pen lewts and im mut and that could make some combat rogues angry but its better than what i had anyway and im going combat when i feel that i have the gear to pull more dps than i am atm ( 8-9k)

[Anarch]

^ you look like a very stabable human. I saw a deadly and a 232, the 264 was nice

NOW DO ME

http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...&cn=Heyimadude

[Turmynator]

^as for the deadly haha i just got my 100 wins achievement but look at my ratings i think its not bad haha but yea if you look at the armory i just got 264 bracers and chest from recent activity they show up

as for your gear i supose you want to pvp first thing id do is get a weapon chain in your off hand its worth it for pvp and is gonna help you alot also you are way over pvp hit cap aka 5 % work on lowering that if possible

[Kryz]

^Some of your pieces i would love for my combat set.
but heres mine.
http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...dare&cn=Kryzik

[Turmynator]

^pretty nice gear well gem'd and hows the tiny jar working for you ?

[Poklix]

Hey. I got skipped lol. My turn
http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...Modan&n=Poklix

[Seratted]

^Some of your pieces i would love for my combat set.
but heres mine.
http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...dare&cn=Kryzik

I guess some of us in the "higher end" of raiding dont get rated? hehe, all i got was a "i'm not one to rate others."

So, i'll rate you and you rate me.

i'm going to go with a 9.75/10. The only reason i go with this instead of a 10/10 is because of Heartpiece - keep in mind this is a PERSONAL OPINION. - i have and have used heartpiece and the stat loss versus my current dagger, Gouge of the Frigid Heart, is too big. I dont think you are close enough to the white crit cap in order to have to drop those stats and while the energy return is very nice, i have still found it to be a DPS loss in real-time fights.

I do give you an extra 0.75 though for a) your mount (0.25), b) TAiaJ (0.25), and C) Tribute to Insanity (0.25).

[Stoghra]

Hey. I got skipped lol. My turn
http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...Modan&n=Poklix

Rating you 'cos ^ didn't have armory link :P Giev your gear :3 that's my rate.

Mine: http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...s&n=Otsonivako (haven't played for a while and my arena partner is at army atm)

[panda911]

The over-expertise is to line me up to lose Vengeance of the Forsaken, putting me at exactly 26 expertise. The gemming, well, I'm not regemming old gear for a .01% increase, it can wait for new drops.

By the way, I'm the #2 Combat rogue on my server, to return your smugness.

Well I sure am glad that you know when upgrade trinkets will drop, but its a wasted stat until the unknown time of replacement .

batmanjl: Level up your engineering. Little too much hit, but what can you do, know what I mean? You are in dire need a new 2nd trinket...get the encrusted scorpian from the new 5 mans. I am a fan of Cat's Swiftness over 16 agi on boots. Get the shoulder enchants from Sons of Hodir. Not terrible, you know? Just small things you can work on, good job man!

[Followthehollow]

Well I sure am glad that you know when upgrade trinkets will drop, but its a wasted stat until the unknown time of replacement .

batmanjl: Level up your engineering. Little too much hit, but what can you do, know what I mean? You are in dire need a new 2nd trinket...get the encrusted scorpian from the new 5 mans. I am a fan of Cat's Swiftness over 16 agi on boots. Get the shoulder enchants from Sons of Hodir. Not terrible, you know? Just small things you can work on, good job man!

Man every time I jump in this thread I can't find anything to pick on the guy above me =P

Uhhh you are 1 exp under cap omgomgomg!

Go easy on me, I'm a casual and I don't do progression raids.

http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...&cn=Anastasyah

[Jiposs]

Man every time I jump in this thread I can't find anything to pick on the guy above me =P

Uhhh you are 1 exp under cap omgomgomg!

Go easy on me, I'm a casual and I don't do progression raids.

http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...&cn=Anastasyah

Impressive to have the gear you have as a casual. You're a bit overcapped on Expertise though, and it seems to me you can't make up your mind about AP/ArP gemming. :P
Pretty decent apart from that, nonetheless.

http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...utus&cn=Jiposs

[Followthehollow]

Impressive to have the gear you have as a casual. You're a bit overcapped on Expertise though, and it seems to me you can't make up your mind about AP/ArP gemming. :P
Pretty decent apart from that, nonetheless.

http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...utus&cn=Jiposs

Just to respond on this one, speadsheet tells me to gem to right where I'm at as ArPen then swap to AP, once I put another ArP gem in, it drops ArP's EP value to like 1.53 for me due to grim toll. I'm riiight below the soft cap. Will go full ArP when I replace grim toll.

As far the exp, I'm 29/26, due to human racial on the sword. Can't do a whole lot about it right now though =D

[Rottenmouth]

http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...rde+High+Lords
Dont be to brutal now. But nice tips would be appreciated ;3

[stabphera]

http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...rde+High+Lords
Dont be to brutal now. But nice tips would be appreciated ;3

You aren't exp capped... at least I don't think.
http://www.wowarmory.com/character-t...e+Cutting+Edge
Hit 80 two days ago.

[Deleted]

http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...alyon&n=Sharqy

Any C&C? I'm aware of the blue trinket (it's just so stupidly good for me), the JC gems (even though I dropped JC a few days ago) and a few leftover Agi gems, which I haven't replaced with AP gems yet.

[Cainick]

Black magic is not worth the loss from berserking. Your fast weapon should go in your main hand as it is a slight dps upgrade due to the poison mechanics. You should invest in herkuml's trinket as it is BiS for mut. 20 agi as you said should be 40ap. Your trinkets can get much better.

[Tekloth]

Black magic is not worth the loss from berserking. Your fast weapon should go in your main hand as it is a slight dps upgrade due to the poison mechanics. You should invest in herkuml's trinket as it is BiS for mut. 20 agi as you said should be 40ap. Your trinkets can get much better.

What he said, apart from the fast MH slow OH, that'd be a dps loss for me atleast.
Can't really comment on cainick since he didn't leave any links.

7/10 for you.

I know I'm a bit over the exp cap, but I'm waiting for both HWT and 10man LDW trinket.

Link in sig

[Deleted]

Black magic is not worth the loss from berserking. Your fast weapon should go in your main hand as it is a slight dps upgrade due to the poison mechanics. You should invest in herkuml's trinket as it is BiS for mut. 20 agi as you said should be 40ap. Your trinkets can get much better.

Both my two spreadsheets value Haste relatively far above AP (only 2ap > 1haste). (15/(35+2))*250 (2 seconds playtime for proccing) = ~101,35 Haste seems better than (15/(45+2))*400 = ~127,7 AP. Plus Black Magic also generally procs with a trinket and my Hyperspeed Accelerators, increasing the effect even more (haste proc stacking).

I don't see why Black Magic would a bad enchant for Rogues in general. It only raised my DPS since I switched to it from Berserking. Ok, even if you're right, it might not be BiS (as opposed to Berserking), but I have to admit it isn't bad either.

[panda911]

Both my two spreadsheets value Haste relatively far above AP (only 2ap > 1haste). (15/(35+2))*250 (2 seconds playtime for proccing) = ~101,35 Haste seems better than (15/(45+2))*400 = ~127,7 AP. Plus Black Magic also generally procs with a trinket and my Hyperspeed Accelerators, increasing the effect even more (haste proc stacking).

I don't see why Black Magic would a bad enchant for Rogues in general. It only raised my DPS since I switched to it from Berserking. Ok, even if you're right, it might not be BiS (as opposed to Berserking), but I have to admit it isn't bad either.

Its bad. It has an internal cooldown, whereas berserking does not. Swap back to berserking.