1. #1181

    Re: Rate The Ret Paladin Above You

    Quote Originally Posted by meag333
    I have made some pretty significant changes in my gear. Armory in my sig. Don't click on the pic, click the link. The pic isnt updated.
    you are missing a jc gem too! Good gear, overall. give you an 8 aswell for reasons stated above.
    Pondering returning.
    Nikoll - Retribution Paladin

  2. #1182

    Re: Rate The Ret Paladin Above You

    Quote Originally Posted by Nikoll
    you are missing a jc gem too! Good gear, overall. give you an 8 aswell for reasons stated above.
    And that is why i posted it. I knew something didnt look right I just couldn't put my finger on it. I had just got the token tonight and i had switched my leggings. I remembered the nightmare tear but forgot the JC gem. Thanks bro.

    Click to see my Armory

  3. #1183

  4. #1184

    Re: Rate The Ret Paladin Above You

    alright gear, but no heroic gear or ICC gear. Miles above hit cap, and still speced into DS. 5/10

    Quote Originally Posted by meag333
    And that is why i posted it. I knew something didnt look right I just couldn't put my finger on it. I had just got the token tonight and i had switched my leggings. I remembered the nightmare tear but forgot the JC gem. Thanks bro.
    NP. I almost did the same tonight. i bought 2 rubies, cut them than said "why do i have a dragon's eye in my bag?"
    Pondering returning.
    Nikoll - Retribution Paladin

  5. #1185

    Re: Rate The Ret Paladin Above You

    Quote Originally Posted by Nikoll
    you are missing a jc gem too! Good gear, overall. give you an 8 aswell for reasons stated above.
    One time I raided for like 3 weeks missing my 3rd JC gem. I felt like such a tool.

  6. #1186

    Re: Rate The Ret Paladin Above You

    I think my week and a half without an active meta might have been worse.
    Pondering returning.
    Nikoll - Retribution Paladin

  7. #1187

    Re: Rate The Ret Paladin Above You

    <--- Forgets to enchant his ashen verdict ring EVERYtime.

  8. #1188

    Re: Rate The Ret Paladin Above You

    No armory link so i guess i'll skip the rating part ..

    Either way .. here's mine ^^ update from last time

    http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...nholdt&cn=Elim

    greetz

  9. #1189

    Re: Rate The Ret Paladin Above You

    http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...ge&cn=Dardanos

    inb4l2gemurringnoob

    just got before bed last night lol

  10. #1190

    Re: Rate The Ret Paladin Above You

    Quote Originally Posted by RB Seagull
    http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...ge&cn=Dardanos

    inb4l2gemurringnoob

    just got before bed last night lol
    dont waste the gem till the str rings come out anyway

  11. #1191
    Deleted

    Re: Rate The Ret Paladin Above You

    Just snagged the polearm off Blood Queen (Bryntroll hasn't dropped yet lol) and rearranged some gear pieces tell me what you think:

    http://armory.wow-europe.com/charact...cn=Dejav%C3%BA

    Anticipating the 4P tier 10 next week unless I calculated my badge gain wrong :>

  12. #1192

    Re: Rate The Ret Paladin Above You

    Quote Originally Posted by Mew
    Just snagged the polearm off Blood Queen (Bryntroll hasn't dropped yet lol) and rearranged some gear pieces tell me what you think:

    http://armory.wow-europe.com/charact...cn=Dejav%C3%BA

    Anticipating the 4P tier 10 next week unless I calculated my badge gain wrong :>
    Wow, you have an insane unbuffed crit rating! Hopefully that makes up for the strength you're missing because your damage range 2060-2476 seems to be quite low for your gear level.

    Are you very close to getting shadow's edge? You look like you're in a great guild so the bloods should be no problem.

    I personally would have used Str/Crit gems in those yellow slots, but your crit is already so high I'm sure the hit/str ones are fine.

    Edit: I just noticed that you used a nightmare tear to get the socket bonus in the polearm of 12 attack power. This is totally not worth it, 10 more str from a 20 str gem would have given you 22ish attack power anyway.

    This is my Armory:

    http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...grand&n=Sasume

  13. #1193
    Deleted

    Re: Rate The Ret Paladin Above You

    Quote Originally Posted by Sasume
    Wow, you have an insane unbuffed crit rating! Hopefully that makes up for the strength you're missing because your damage range 2060-2476 seems to be quite low for your gear level.

    Are you very close to getting shadow's edge? You look like you're in a great guild so the bloods should be no problem.

    I personally would have used Str/Crit gems in those yellow slots, but your crit is already so high I'm sure the hit/str ones are fine.

    Edit: I just noticed that you used a nightmare tear to get the socket bonus in the polearm of 12 attack power. This is totally not worth it, 10 more str from a 20 str gem would have given you 22ish attack power anyway.

    This is my Armory:

    http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...grand&n=Sasume
    Oh haha just checked, and I accidentially logged out in my prot spec.

    Should look better now with a damage range of 2184-2624 and 52.5% critical chance.

    Actually I don't know how the hell I managed to get my crit that high, but I just amassed some very sick agi pieces over the months and this weapon just put me over the top! I'm kinda liking it hehe.

    But I'm probably not gonna pick up Shadow's Edge for a long while, mostly because our officer death knight has been chosen for the Shadowmourne. That mean's it will be months and months before the next guy is considered (I am probably next in line if we ever get a 2nd legendary, but we'll see), so I didnt really want to spend almost 50.000 gold for a weapon that is comparable to 264 bryntroll. And badges will be way better spend on tier pieces, so no shadow's edge for me

    As for the hit/crit gems I just use em to reach the cap since I'm lacking another good hit piece to avoid gemming for it. Will probably get the strenght neck from deathwhisper that you are using, but rawr doesn't list it as an upgrade over my current setup, so I'm decently satisfied for now.

    Would like a heroics death choice already, but twins are being stubborn bitches!

    Anyway I'll rate you 8.5 / 10, I like your gear choices it seems to know what you are doing. And FU for having Brynskill I really wanted that just for the sexyness of the proc.

    Only thing I would try to do, is get rid of some of your excess expertise so you can go back to using SoV glyph. Cause with 2pT10 you won't be using exorcism much at all, and the glyph is then kinda wasted. The belt would be a good candidate to replace if you can get either of the 3 agi belts (Astrylians cinch, Soulthiefs braided, Linked Scourge vertebrae).


  14. #1194

    Re: Rate The Ret Paladin Above You

    Thanks, good call on the belt

  15. #1195

    Re: Rate The Ret Paladin Above You


    http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sheet.xml?r=Zenedar&cn=Ryadan

  16. #1196

    Re: Rate The Ret Paladin Above You

    http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...ge&cn=Dardanos

    QQ i didnt get rated up above haha, i seem to have low AP? see a lot more ap on other paladins but maybe thats because im missing deaths choice

    for ryadin - would say replace the agi neck, im running agi cape like yours, have the str one from toc 25 but it puts me even further over hit cap. also, would replace mark of supremacy, just dont like those trinkets personally, shoot for the whispering fanged skull or death's choice.

  17. #1197

    Re: Rate The Ret Paladin Above You

    Quote Originally Posted by RB Seagull
    http://www.wowarmory.com/character-s...ge&cn=Dardanos

    QQ i didnt get rated up above haha, i seem to have low AP? see a lot more ap on other paladins but maybe thats because im missing deaths choice

    for ryadin - would say replace the agi neck, im running agi cape like yours, have the str one from toc 25 but it puts me even further over hit cap. also, would replace mark of supremacy, just dont like those trinkets personally, shoot for the whispering fanged skull or death's choice.
    7/10:

    Why did you get the Herkuml Wartoken before 2p t10?
    You ignored all the good yellow slots => 10 crit / 10 Str should be in all of them.
    Used the prisma gem in the wrong slot => place it in your boots instead.

  18. #1198

    Re: Rate The Ret Paladin Above You

    Quote Originally Posted by Nillo
    7/10:

    Why did you get the Herkuml Wartoken before 2p t10?
    You ignored all the good yellow slots => 10 crit / 10 Str should be in all of them.
    Used the prisma gem in the wrong slot => place it in your boots instead.
    9/10 i would say because of the non str items but who am i to judge i have yet to see some better stuff drop for me.

    here is mine http://eu.wowarmory.com/character-sh...&cn=Aldassador

    please dont mind the Kirin Tor ring i replaced it with Ashens Revered ring and VotF with NES (i know there both not that good but i never seen Skull dropping in icc)
    I started the Book of Faces moving
    Was involved in the RP Invasion

    /Brofisting Vol'Jin

  19. #1199
    Pandaren Monk Swampmoose's Avatar
    15+ Year Old Account
    Join Date
    Jul 2008
    Location
    San Diego
    Posts
    1,763

    Re: Rate The Ret Paladin Above You

    Quote Originally Posted by ProphetNoata
    dont waste the gem till the str rings come out anyway
    It will probably be worse than the agility one.

  20. #1200

    Re: Rate The Ret Paladin Above You

    Quote Originally Posted by Swampmoose
    It will probably be worse than the agility one.
    At least with 2p t9 :>

Posting Permissions

  • You may not post new threads
  • You may not post replies
  • You may not post attachments
  • You may not edit your posts
  •