Originally Posted by
PraisetheSun
Well, considering that the melee damage on 10-man HC Garrosh is completely predictable (and an outright joke), the fact that AMS neither scales with vengeance (at least AFAIK) nor is percentage-based DR, that Blood DK DPS barely keeps up with prot paladins, AND that they bring no raid CD or any sort of raid utility really, I feel sorta warranted saying they're meh for Garrosh. They do less DPS than warriors and they're less self-sufficient than paladins.
I mean, could they be worse? Sure, they could be Monks. No tank in the current tier is ever going to be as good at solo-tanking a fight as prot paladins, though - maybe outside of some bogus 1-tank, kill Ka'roz early and break Amber with his buff Paragons deal, where obviously you'd want a monk tank and a paladin in the raid to HoP them. Not that anyone is crazy enough to try it, which is a shame.