Originally Posted by
TelefonoGatewood
So I guess me and most of my guild could be classified as "hardcore casuals" - we've been raiding together since Vanilla (well EQ) with a goal of clearing the hardest raid content "in time". So reasonably competitive - but not going for that top 1-50 bracket (in fact, we were considerably worse than that - 300-400). This has worked fine, event though it was made much harder with the introduction of Mythic and maintenance of 20-man rosters on servers with dwindling pops.
The straw that broke us was Legion and the time investment required to "stay competitive" - not necessarily as a guild, but as individual players. The randomness and the grinds and the constant "need" to be logged in every night killed it - attrition set in and everyone quit the game.
WoD, in many ways, catered directly to me and my guild. We just liked to raid (hard content) and log and go play something else when done. No silly grinds, no huge requirements, just some fluff story and that's it. It even had a huge PvP zone for that "just for lolz" type of play in the off evenings. It was good and didn't get in your face every evening requiring "more AP" or "more legoes"
It was quite good imho, but the public opinion is that it's the worst possible expac ever. On the other hand people seem to love Legion.
I've come to realise that what I want, is probably not what most people want and it wouldn't make any sense for Blizzard to repeat WoD just to cater to me - and they won't. If anything they'll run fast to the opposite direction (and they seem to be going that way with BfA).