Originally Posted by
Thagrynor
I would say this is a little different though than the DH situation. DH's only really took 1 major ability from Warlocks, namely Meta. Granted, it was a HUGE part of Demo, but it was honestly a part of Demo that never really fit lorewise. Demo was meant to show domination over demons, not really becoming a demon. That was always a Demon Hunter thing. So, DH were really taking back that which should have belonged to them in the first place.
With Dark Rangers, every ability they have is basically an MM ability. And the hunters weren't stealing these abilities from Dark Rangers, like Warlocks did with Meta. Additionally, Dark Rangers make zero sense lorewise, as Dark Rangers are Sylvanas's bodyguards. How would you explain them being on the Alliance? It would be some half-assed convoluted explanation that no one would be happy with. The BEST they could do might be ... "Well, a Void Elf used to be a Dark Ranger before becoming a Void Elf so .... huzzah! Dark Rangers!" which would be horrible.
I honestly can't imagine Blizzard, for all their faults with BFA, coming out and thinking Dark Rangers would be a good idea. Or maybe I just don't WANT to believe they could do something so terrible.
As others have said, I personally think Tinker is the only class that would make sense from the standpoint of having interesting lore, not having to steal most of their abilities from other classes and have a new feel/aesthetic/class fantasy. We don't have any mechanical classes. That alone is enough for it to be something different and new. Plus, since they are mechanical, you are literally able to explain them doing any role you want by creating the necessary mechanical tools for them to accomplish the role. They need to tank? They got a mechsuit and armor plating and forcefield like shields. They need to heal? Alchemy-based healing using things like the healing darts and healing mist grenades like the Mercenary healer in SWTOR. They need to DPS? They could be melee or ranged (though I am hoping only ranged. There is WAY too much melee in the game already!) with the appropriate weapons and tools. Plus, with ranged, if they make it a mail wearing class (we need more mail classes), they could also use guns which means maybe they would also add Pistols as 1h guns that could be dual wielded, which would be amazing. Because that would also let hunters potentially use them. Or make the Pistol a Tinker only weapon like Glaives are for DH. So much potential.