Originally Posted by
Arrashi
Bingo we have a winner.
To be fair, everything about Warcraft is copy paste, which is why the high elf hate surprises me a lot when those who passionately hate it because they're "Tolkein elves" they claim.
Everything in wow or most things are copy pasted from popular fantasy. I am surprised we haven't got a Star wars copy yet, what is charming about blizzard is usually how they adapt many of these things, and the fact that all your favourite pop culture variants are in one place and It has a cohesive story.
I mean, that's at least what I like most about Warcraft - the lore has proven to fall short far too many times for me to idolise it, which is a bit shocking for such a renowned and long lived media series ( I would expect less mistakes than they've made), but despite some of the glaring thigns, we are all still a bit interested because there are things we're quite fond of
I like most of the adaptations, not all though, then after that, I don't always like some of the things they emphaises and am sometimes irritated by some of thet higns they seemingly leave forgotten which were actually nice touches.
I was most impressed by the Dark elf adapation of the night elves into a not evil fused arcane/nature duality race, then instead of living underground in caves had a star light/moonlight ..i.e. night SKY emphasis in them containing a wide range of diversity within that race and its function (when you think of their arcane, nature, Divine, fel, and light/void expertise, with archers/hunters and warriors and the interesting gender swap without being weird or feminist) I really liked that as compared to other fantasies, dark elves were typically very monotonous and evil - hence whey I use to be quite outspoken when communities left no room for the other facets of the night elves outside nature.
Orcs and blood elves (also void elves) were another twist I liked. Orcs were cunning, intelligent, whiles maintaining their savage and brutish edge.. but they weren't dumb like in many portrayals, and Warcraft and LotR were the only two fantasy worlds were orcs actually felt dangerous, but Warcraft the only one were they were redeemable and again had this diverse range and reach, not just limited to "the savage warrior ME SMASH" portrayal. However the fact that is how orcs are perceived in other fantasies, plays out quite well, as this view of orcs is often held by arrogant races like elves and humans, yet is far from the truth.
Blood elves exploring the magical addiction started in the night elf story and turning out to be less than the upstanding morally perfect and virtuous high elf was also interesting. I definitely found Tolkein's high elves interesting and how he managed to portray them as he described them, an impressive feat I have now learned as nearly every other fantasy has failed to get immortality/long lived or highly intelligent races (as they describe portrayed). The blood elves however were flawed elves morally, but with the cunning high intelligence of the race, keeping their beautiful appearance, but being quite the opposite (in many cases) on the inside, was great, they offered both the hope of returning to their nobler past yet not and offering a more devious feel to the blood elves without going the all out evil/crazy that competing elven groups (like dark elves usually have). My only gripe is actually not really with them, but the lack of the night elven group being out paced by the blood elves because it doesn't fit the original lore, night elves are supposed to be by default superior in every aspect, magical aptitude, intelligence, longevity, stature - but they aren't as ambitious as the blood elves and are crippled by shame and guilt because of the sundering - yet they were initially shown to be sterner and more commanding only to have them fad e to nothing which I have always felt isn't a good move, because of how popular the high elf is, you always need to make your dark/night elf one step ahead to compete, and I felt that the night elves have the racial background to provide that, but it isn't utilised in wow at all and that's because of gameplay facors.
However I digress, most of wow is ripped form somewhere, but it's cool because we like their taste. undead is basically the zombie apocalypse, except they become cool and do metal with funky punk hairstylesz, worgen/vamps are out of suprentaural. elves/dwarves/trolls/orcs - classic tolkein dirved fantasy, etc.. mages and wizards, dark elves, kung fu panda, demons too etc. They make it work even though they sometimes go too far (the new titan lore or twisting the light with the whole Xe'ra/Illidan thing) or do un-necessary twists (like Nelves from trolls). But for the most parts I quite like it, deven with a lot of stuff mentioned that isn't later developed or used.