Originally Posted by
EnigmAddict
This, the problem is wow has all these amazing races, and tehy are, great character, great individualisation, amazing backdrops, but they are ruined when you try to ham fist htem into a horde or alliance puritan theme. They lose that awesome uniqueness and just become written in to fit horde or alliance - which makes the way they are doing the factions the problem And why i want a race expansion.
They really could have done alll of it better, for s tarters, alliance and horde as an entity did not have to consume everything, they could have mainly been humans/dwarves/gnomes and orcs/trolls/tauren - the other races like night elves, blood elves , forsaken, draenei are really all their own thing. They didn't have to be converted to fit the alliance, cut down to fit the humans or lessa tractive than the humans, moulded to be more horde like (which they did to bothe the blood elves and forsaken ) then later on they started to try and change the identity of the horde to sort of fit all the differnet races or fit the high elf (blood elf - b/c these ones weren't the original blood elves these are blood elves becoming high elves again) and you get lots of inconsistenceies.
I bet this is how night elvs have been ruined, forsaken and blood elves just not meshing and every attempt to hamfist them in further - an undead warchief makes it worse. IT is homogenizing which was totally unnecessary.
Sometimes tell an alliance v horde conflict but let it be largely a human/dwarf/gnome vs orc/troll/tauren/goblin - then tell a blood elf story, and then a forsaken one, and then a night elf story, sometimes you can do them both together, like the night elves and blood elves could be in a story, like the blood elves and draenei were where it was the story of the race, and it wasn't so much as the alliance this or the horde that. You didn't see blood elves in Garadar Nagrand cosying up to orcs because they were in the same faction, nor did you see orcs, trolls or forsaken in the netherstorm or in Falcon Watch Hellfire peninsular, their stories were separate - horde forces would have the token forsaken or token blood elf, not have to be this whole integrated thing.
the races are too different for that, if you are going to do a 2 faction system, you can't make the faction identity all consuming at the expense of the racial one. At best night elves should be very loosely allied to the alliance, at best. Blood elves should not change at all from being in the horde out of convenience, not out of love - it's not a happy family of we all love each other and this needs to be shown clearly because the player gets to go into all these places, it should be clear a blood elf ain't interested, or it's all a matter of honour for an orc.