Originally Posted by
Viscoe
I came from a realm in WoW where our server was so shitty and non-progressed that shit guilds from better realms would transfer there to steal server firsts. It happened literally every raid tier until MoP, when the Alliance side (we were always 1:.6 or so, Alliance dominated) got their superior pop together and were able to make a functioning 10man that could raid heroics.
It's a population problem, not a lack of talent problem. That said, a lot of the people I knew and am friends with from the RP server I was on for 7 years (Blackwater Raiders) were totally fucking terrible and I don't know how they can continue to play video games without being so frustrated that they quit. I don't know how the fuck you can die in a starter zone, but they managed it.
Anyways, assuming RP servers attract a lot more people of lesser talent, because they seem to (as they attract some players who aren't focused even on reaching level cap sometimes) then assume that they're some of the lowest populated servers, you can see where the problem lies. The pool of players is small. The talent, therefore, is not as abundant.
But then you look at realms like Moon Guard and Wyrmrest Accord, who have real populations, and you see that they have 20+ 10man guilds raiding H 10s and at least 3 raiding H 25s, and it's like, "Oh." Nothing about being an RPer makes it so that you can't play. But since Blizz is bad at realms, people get this misconception and it's saddening. :/