Originally Posted by
Yakrion
A few thoughts:
There's no reason to keep the thread from three years ago. It's just 25 pages of bloat to get to any relevant posts/discussion, so making a new thread would've been better.
I play BM primarily and I haven't simmed it so I may be completely mistaken, but I see stampede / AMoC / Dire Beast having a higher priority than ES and it makes me question it.
The criticism about copying from EJ is accurate. I don't think you did copy-paste, but it feels very much like I'm reading that guide.
The formatting for much of it is more spread than it needs to be, enchants and gems specifically.
For the section on petbuffs, I suggest googling 'Mists of Pandaria buffs debuffs and abilities Kalliope' and using that chart instead, as it's a much more compact and easier to read table and has the side effect of making hunters more aware of what other classes bring without needed an addon or to ask someone. I would post the link myself, but apparently I need a higher post count for that.
My biggest criticism is that the guide really only covers the very basics and could go way more indepth on fight-by-fight tricks/tips (condensing information available elsewhere) and going into more advanced steps of how to fine-tune your dps once you start getting past the easy dps gains from doing the right priority and getting 4pc/trinkets/weapons/legendary cloak. That said, you did put out a solid guide covering the basics, so good job there.