Originally Posted by
Imagidin
Really? I thought it was really easy and quite safe to 1 tank it as a prot paladin. Can understand if lower gear but in the gear most guilds now have on thok hc, I dont understand why you wouldnt 1 tank it if the other tank has a viable dps offspec. We sometimes do it with a dk 1 tanking it, and its a bit unreliable, I think he dies like 1 time in every 5 pulls, particular if he forgets to swap trinkets before fight, but also seemed quite doable. But overall I think 1 tanking it is perfectly viable and not really something to steer away from if tanks feel comfortable doing it. If he needs a bit of help resto druid and disc have pretty good cooldowns to give him at critical points. And there really only really a few critical points, stacks above 6 on first part of thok, tanking jailer if when he enrages(can always soothe him) and you have stacks, tanking bats and boss and when you get into iceblock on ice phase.
I would suggest you use your warrior to solo tank tho, its a lot more stabile than dk.