Indeed i agree but people can speculate and defend whatever they want but none will be right until we actually had the answers from seeing it ourself but with the shown grown interest over the phast years for the hunger of vanila servers i can only assume it could go 1 direction.
Take a look on Minecraft, they have legacy servers, it went good for them but sure that's a whole other story but people do want legacy servers
It has nothing to do with Nostalgia though. I met plenty of people who had never played vanilla, and some never even played WoW before, and all of them say Nostalrius has been one of their best gaming experiences.
You're right that people progress through the content a lot faster, but that's only possible if all the content is released from the start. Nostalrius released content progressively, just like WoW did with patches back in vanilla.
Well, truth to be told, if they can avoid the bad marketing - that deleting lower population servers is - and instead manage to go for "cross-realm technology", thus keeping said lower population servers alive.. it can't be that harsh for them to have, keep and maintain servers.
There is no way to know how much the retention rate would be on Vanilla\Legacy type of servers - there would be loses, as there are everywhere, but there is no way to know how much the actual number is.
I'm going to bet that the biggest factor is that they can't phantom that players want a different game than the one they want to push out, their vision. Which is, obviously, completely within their right.
That might not be a good thing, Blizz would have to provide enough Vanilla servers to deal with a massive rush at the start, then begin the whole process of merging and transferring when the numbers stabilise. I just can't see Vanilla severs being a good use of resources.
Well you're right there is other private servers out there and to conclude it i'd like to see them adding one private server of each expansion.
That would give the game a longer life spawn. People can progress on vanila for months, bored? progress or start over again but in the TBC server and so on.
I think that could be pretty damn good with a extra charged fee option for people who want this and again i think there is a lot of people who would want it, you can see that by the support of the articles about nost, youtubers and this whole blown up thing on forums.
No doubt in my mind people would demand content and updates several months into a legacy server.
In what way is it insane? A team of 30 (that includes GMs and testers, developers is more likely closer to 10) were able to do it reasonably well without anything to go after other than memory and scarce resources on the internet, why wouldn't Blizzard be able to do it when they even have the source?
They could start a few servers every year in vanilla and progress through the expansions again, and it wouldn't even be very expensive for them to do it.
Newsflash for the anti legacy server guys: Then those guys are not quite the target audience here. As people who want Vanilla WoW want just that - vanilla wow. Not [whatever updates might be introduced].
People want to experience the Ever-Evolving World? Regular servers are said way.
#PrayforNostalrius
#NostalriusGate
Feel free to use those, constantly.