Just because it has the same name doesn't mean it's the same game.
Blink 182 just came out with a single without the main guitarist/singer, which sounds exactly like the bassists spinoff band. Just because they're using the name Blink 182 doesn't mean it is Blink 182.
Just because The Force Awakens has Star Wars in front of it and Star Wars skins doesn't mean it's Star Wars.
Real WoW died with the Lich King.
People who say they play vanilla servers because they enjoy the challenge are just plain liars. Vanilla was a lot less challenging than WoD is. The raiding, which is the be all and end all of WoW (stop lying to yourself. It is), is exactly 17.3 times harder on normal in WoD than it is in Vanilla. We all know this is true. The raiding in Vanilla is probably on the same level of LFR in WoD when it comes to mechanics. The rest of Vanilla is just a bunch of grinding. Grind that trade chat to get a group. Grind those mobs to be able to ride your mount at the correct speed. Going to raid and you are in a shit guild which 99.4% of people were? Grind those mats for 15 hours a week. GRINDING SHIT IS NOT COMPELLING GAMEPLAY AND IT ISN'T A CHALLENGE. It is just grinding.
The two reasons people play vanilla servers are:
1. The game just got too hard for them. Raids with 40 people were very easy to hide the bads. Vanilla had the easiest raids with the best way to hide the shitload of bads who did the raids. When they moved to 25 man in BC there was a massive outcry because "25 people is just not epic enough". In reality it was just because the bads were too scared that they were going to be exposed in the smaller raids. As the expansions rolled out, the raids got more complicated and the bads just got fed up with being called out as shit and left the game.
2. People are thieving bastards and they do not want to pay for a WoW account. We all know this is true because the biggest thieving server got shut down because the majority of its 1-2 million players (as quoted by an internet star in a video, hahahahaha. The server's own figures stated 80K.) were too cheap to donate to the server to keep it running. Some people say it was Blizzard who shut them down yet thousands of players said that Blizzard had no right. If Blizzard had no right as a lot of you thieves have claimed then why did this server shut down? It is because, even though most of you claimed you would pay for a vanilla server, no one paid for a vanilla server and the people running the server took what was left and ran.
TL;DR
People who "like" vanilla are
Thieves
Liars
Shit at the game
Do not know what "good" or compelling means
Are the Nost boys fanatical? Perhaps a lil, that's because once you try out vanilla, you don't want to go back lol. Hard to find an accurate description but it's like watching the original Matrix movie or watching the crappy Matrix Revolutions movie instead. Despite being a few years older, it's still light years better.
Played Classic 10 years ago, played Classic less than a week ago. Community was still as bad as I remember.
Prefer the game Wrath-MoP (Wod was disappointing) to now.
The most accurate description I could give would be that the Classic Wow fan boys are like the Amish. Refuse to join the rest of the civilized world and remain in the past.
This doesn't even make any sense. They are literally the same game in that one is patch 1.12.1 and once is patch 6.2 but they are not mutually exclusive because the difference in the game between the 2 is monumental.
It's really only the story that ties them together.
"kinda exclusive to the people who matter"
What were you trying to say here because this doesnt make sense. Something is mutually exclusive or it is not.