Well, let me see your data on that. And does it include their children as well? Another problem is their income, since they tend not to have any skill to earn money. Thus, they depend on Earned Income tax Credit and Child Tax Credit. Therefore, they get more in refund then they paid in tax.
- - - Updated - - -
But you do not agree with freedom either. If you did that, you would be against unions and for open border. You would have supported U.S. turning into third world country.