Originally Posted by
Archimtiros
Well any bonus should make the spec feel better with it than without it, but that doesn't mean that every bonus is "mandatory" either. In fact very few are, which is why very few are ever baked in. Not to mention that baking a bonus in while the tier/expansion is still current causes gear issues as the bonus on existing gear needs to be changed - wasting development time.
Personally, I don't think either of the bonuses we have are, they could be easily replicated in other ways. Simply increasing BT's crit chance (or any other change which increases Enrage uptime) accomplishes the same basic goal. Funny enough, both tier bonuses actually devalue quite noticeably as BT's crit rate/rage gen/rampage use increase.
I would call something like a fix for crit more of a "mandatory" bonus, as without it, crit continues to be a universally avoided stat.