Smashsmite was 1-shotting Mythic NH geared tanks on +10s when CoEN came out.
Yeah, it was overtuned.
- - - Updated - - -
The tuning had serious issues on certain affixes. TBC and Cata dungeons were tough, but there was not the same difficulty variance we have today with the M+ system. CoEN was almost impossible on certain affixes at high key levels. Thats an issue.