"Ideal" 10man *CLASS* Raid

[chrisnumbers]

You're going to do a 10man, a serious one. Maybe it's ToGC, or ICC, or ICC hardmodes, or Ulduar hardmodes, or whatever. But you want to maximize your group's potential.

Here's the twist, hypothetically:

You have to bring every class; 1 of each.
You have to have 2 tanks and 3 healers; 1 of the healers you choose will be allowed to bring a dps offspec, but no one else.

What would you bring?

[Talio]

Warrior tank
Death Knight tank
Rogue
Mage
Hunter
Warlock
Paladin Healer
Shaman DPS - Ench
Priest Healer
Druid Healer with DPs offspec.

[Karmarama]

Tanks:
Prot Warrior
Bear Druid

Heals:
Holy Paladin
Holy Priest
Resto Shaman/OS Elemental

DPS:
Demo Warlock
Arcane Mage
MM Hunter
Unholy DK
Mut Rogue

[Restraint]

Warrior - Tank
Paladin - Holy
Priest - Holy or disc, depends on fight tbh
Shaman - Resto w/ ele offspec
Druid - Feral
Death Knight -UH dps
Rogue -Combat
Hunter - MM
Warlock - Demo
Mage - frost for replenishment

First draft, atleast. Sucks have to bring all 4 pures tbh >.>

[Namist]

Tanks:
Prot Warrior
Bear Druid

Heals:
Holy Paladin
Holy Priest
Resto Shaman/OS Elemental

DPS:
Demo Warlock
Arcane Mage
MM Hunter
Unholy DK
Mut Rogue

^ this win win

[Deleted]

^ this win win

I second that.

[Fuzza]

Tanks:
Prot Warrior
Bear Druid

Heals:
Holy Paladin
Holy Priest
Resto Shaman/OS Elemental

DPS:
Demo Warlock
Arcane Mage
MM Hunter
Unholy DK
Mut Rogue

Warning - while you were reading a new reply has been posted. You may wish to review your post.

Was writing same thing its prolly best.

[Shannerd]

Tanks
Warrior
Death Knight

Healers
Disc Priest
Resto Druid with kitty offspec
Resto Shaman

DPS
MM Hunter
Arcane Mage
Demo Warlock
Combat Rogue
Ret Paladin

[kravien]

Holy Palla
Resto Druid
Resto Shaman

Tanking DK
Prot Warrior

Shadow Priest
Assasionation Rogue
MM Hunter
Demo Lock
Fire Mage

This was how I thought:
Imo holy palla and resto druid are the beast healers for 10 man so I want to bring those.,
then I need a third healer and since I only have shaman and priest left I would have to go with shaman since I need the priest to be shadow for the 3% spell hit.

The only classes that can tank now is warrior and DK so thats a no-brainer.
And then its just 4 pure dps classes and a shadowpriest.

I´m not sure this is the ideal group but its at least a group I would enjoy raiding with, it got my favorite class/specc combinations in it :P

And got most of the raidbuffs.

[Findus707]

Tanks:
Prot Warrior
Bear Druid

Heals:
Holy Paladin
Holy Priest
Resto Shaman/OS Elemental

DPS:
Demo Warlock
Arcane Mage
MM Hunter
Unholy DK
Mut Rogue

[Jartin]

Tanks:
Druid
Druid

Heals:
Druid
Druid
Druid

DPS:
Druid
Druid
Druid
Druid
Druid

[kaze950]

Speaking from the hunter perspective that is a good team but the absence of a ret pally just means your hunter will be hitting OOM fast and hard so i personaly would swap out the unholy DK for a ret pally, and for good measure the lock for a shadow priest so my set up would be :-

Tanks

Warrior
Drood

Heals

Disc Priest with a holy offspec for certain fights
Holy Pally
Resto Shammy (ele offspec)

DPS

Arcane Mage
Ret Pally
Marks Hunter
Muti Rogue with combat offspec
Shadow Priest

Think you missed "You have to bring every class; 1 of each." :P

[Herecius]

I see a lot of raid comps here with both rogues and MM hunters, yet the same raid comps don't have a feral druid bleed debuff. Would be good to take note of that.

[Shazzia]

Warning - while you were reading a new reply has been posted. You may wish to review your post.

Was writing same thing its prolly best.

why is bear so good? I mean they can ONLY dodge, and Chill of the Throne 'gives' -20% dodge...

[Xelaeno]

Why does everyone put the only battle rezzer as the tank?

[Reynard]

RaidComp Loadout

Tanks:
Warrior
Blood DK

Healers:
Disc Priest
Resto Shaman
Holy Paladin

DPS:
Arcane Mage
Demonology Warlock
Combat Rogue
Survival Hunter
Balance Druid

Some simple decisions: The four pure dps classes will take four dps slots. I discard Frost, Beast Mastery, and Subtlety out of hand; I select Demonology (for Demonic Pact - large spell power boost and Improved Shadow Bolt - 5% spell crit), Combat (for Savage Combat - 4% physical damage), and Arcane (Arcane Empowerment - 3% damage). A Survival Hunter brings Replenishment.

The last DPS slot should either go to a Boomkin or Shadow Priest. Since we already have Replenishment and Boomkins bring a huge package of buffs, Boomkin makes five.

After that it was just filling in blanks; since the dps slots were taken, a Resto Shaman pops out naturally, and a Disc Priest is taken over a Holy Priest for Renewed Hope.

[Thylin]

Dk Tank
Druid Tank

Pala Healer
Priest Healer - DPS offspec
Shaman Healer

Rogue combat
Warrior fury
Hunter mm
Warlock demo
Mage arcane

Dont people know that warrior tanks are useless and fury warriors are insane?

[kravien]

why is bear so good? I mean they can ONLY dodge, and Chill of the Throne 'gives' -20% dodge...

I'm not saying bear is the best tank right now or anything, just froze my account so I´m not really up to date, but the -20% dodge effects all tank equally (yes all tanks have more then 20% dodge in ICC) so it not a bigger disadvantage for them.
In fact its an advantage for druid tanks since they relay less on avoidance then other tanks and more on raw HP and Armour, so when avoidance gets nerfed and all tanks have to take a few more hits the druid tanks will take those hits better then the other tanks.

[Feandil]

Tanks:
Prot war
Dk ( blood prolly )

Healers:
Disc priest ( rly, they save your ass on lk 10 hc)
Resto shammy ( ele os)
Resto druid

Dps:
MM Hunter
Demo lock
Ret paladin
Mage ( whatever spec, all mages are the same )
Combat rogue

[Omgponies]

Dont people know that warrior tanks are useless and fury warriors are insane?

I feel that you play a warrior as dps, and needed to tell everyone just how good your class is?