Mafia game discussion thread.

[ELYPOP]

Waker, go to party or get pictures of testicles sent to your phone.

(Did I make him uncomfortable enough?)

Can I also get these pictures? Thaanks!

[Decagon]

Whatchu talkin' 'bout Willis?
There were 7 scum out of 25 players in a time limited game.

I meant more in comparison to the Drow game.

[Arlee]

Well really in the Drow game everyone except one person was scum

[Decagon]

Well really in the Drow game everyone except one person was scum

I thought there were like 3. Danner, Catta, Silkku.

[Anakso]

The entire game I did nothing but vote for the guy who would have won us the game and the only person who joined in was Ely :<

[Blood Fox]

ok I'm going to do the only thing That I know how to do. complain

I don't think we should be locking the game threads very quickly, perhaps a week after the game. The reason being is when i want to look at posts about the game I need to come in here and find the corresponding dates to see discussion about a game. I also feel that it stifles discussion about the game by having that thread being locked.

[Loaf]

The entire game I did nothing but vote for the guy who would have won us the game and the only person who joined in was Ely :<

just a note, lynching silkku wouldn't have won the town the game :P I still had the ability to use the reindeer for killing and no one had any idea of Rudolph's existence before the game ended. Even if Silkku had been lynched and Rudolph was revealed, I don't think it would've been seen as me :P

[Anakso]

just a note, lynching silkku wouldn't have won the town the game :P I still had the ability to use the reindeer for killing and no one had any idea of Rudolph's existence before the game ended. Even if Silkku had been lynched and Rudolph was revealed, I don't think it would've been seen as me :P

It's possible, we'll never know now because no one was willing to lynch silkku! :<

- - - Updated - - -

ok I'm going to do the only thing That I know how to do. complain

I don't think we should be locking the game threads very quickly, perhaps a week after the game. The reason being is when i want to look at posts about the game I need to come in here and find the corresponding dates to see discussion about a game. I also feel that it stifles discussion about the game by having that thread being locked.

The discussing just moves here.

[Decagon]

just a note, lynching silkku wouldn't have won the town the game :P I still had the ability to use the reindeer for killing and no one had any idea of Rudolph's existence before the game ended. Even if Silkku had been lynched and Rudolph was revealed, I don't think it would've been seen as me :P

I'm not sure. I was pretty convinced you were a killer in the Dead Thread.

It's possible, we'll never know now because no one was willing to lynch silkku! :<

Scum or not, team members try to avoid lynching each other.

[Loaf]

dead probably had lots of infos to help convince :P

[listo95]

dead probably had lots of infos to help convince :P

Actually, we were kept in the dark until the last night/day phase pretty much.

[Anakso]

I did say there was a reason people weren't willing to lynch silkku beyond the "he's more useful" bit, that alone just did not make sense.

Take note everyone, if that is the only reason people are giving for not voting someone there is probably another reason they're not saying

[Deleted]

Yeah, take notice of how the guy that said it the most wasn't even scum

[Waker]

It's because we decided only a couple days in advance and everyone else managed to change their plans to be able to come. S&E are going over to Langelmäki and still making it back on time

I'm not single so I can't help it :b

I know that the case is "kinda" similar for other of our friends too but I don't live with my girlfriend yet.

[Danner]

I thought there were like 3. Danner, Catta, Silkku.

In the drow game, myself, catta, sillkku, falbacca and kisuro were not scum.
Out of these, Silkku and Catta were heavily trying to sell out their own team.

But yeah, Decagon, I can see why you think the games were similar.

[Catta]

In the drow game, myself, catta, sillkku, falbacca and kisuro were not scum.
Out of these, Silkku and Catta were heavily trying to sell out their own team.

But yeah, Decagon, I can see why you think the games were similar.

Actually I didn't sell out a single of my own teammates.

Which is pretty lucky considering I didn't know them.

Also they tried to kill me.

And the other team also tried to kill me... twice.


End up getting lynched...

[Arlee]

I thought there were like 3. Danner, Catta, Silkku.

In the drow game, myself, catta, sillkku, falbacca and kisuro were not scum.
Out of these, Silkku and Catta were heavily trying to sell out their own team.

But yeah, Decagon, I can see why you think the games were similar.

Not really. Both Catta and Danner could have been recruited by the scum factions so while they started as townies they could become scum which made them traitors (who are scum). I am pretty sure Silkku only could have been recruited if everyone else on their team died/was recruited first. Also I think Silkku had to be alive and unrecruited to win that game and that was the only possibility for town to win.

[Uggorthaholy]

Not really. Both Catta and Danner could have been recruited by the scum factions so while they started as townies they could become scum which made them traitors (who are scum). I am pretty sure Silkku only could have been recruited if everyone else on their team died/was recruited first. Also I think Silkku had to be alive and unrecruited to win that game and that was the only possibility for town to win.

Yep, basically this.

[Catta]

I even mentioned the recruit thing on the very first day and still they didn't try to recruit ANY power role.

Also a whole game of traitors trying to act as if they were townies was hilarious in hindsight

[Krayzy]

just a note, lynching silkku wouldn't have won the town the game :P I still had the ability to use the reindeer for killing and no one had any idea of Rudolph's existence before the game ended. Even if Silkku had been lynched and Rudolph was revealed, I don't think it would've been seen as me :P

You would have been able to perform night kills, but unless you all role claimed in the thread you had no way to get the other reindeer to vote with you like Silkku did. All the reindeer followed his lead because they knew who he was. They had no idea about you or your role though.