Batman: Arkham Mafia

[Decagon]

Vote Arlee
I doubt her explanation will be good enough.

@Deca
Survivors just want to live, they should win regardless of what team. This makes them neutral, but since there are more town than scum, and they are very likely to die with the town if the scum start becoming a majority, they should play town most of the time.

Okay, that's what I was thinking, but I just wanted to be sure.

[Krayzy]

My head hurts. I don't have a clue about anything in this game right now.

Someone, anyone, give me some direction. Preferably more than just a vote on a person. Some actual reasoning behind it would be nice.

[Dyra]

I would very much like to hear Arlee's rebuttal on Worgie's vote, but it seems Worgie has sniffed something out successfully given he's gone straight in with the vote, and will give us his own reasoning once Arlee responds.

*waits patiently*

[Decagon]

My head hurts. I don't have a clue about anything in this game right now.

Someone, anyone, give me some direction. Preferably more than just a vote on a person. Some actual reasoning behind it would be nice.

Seems the reasoning is coming from a defense from Arlee. So the direction here could be to just wait a bit.

[Krayzy]

I would very much like to hear Arlee's rebuttal on Worgie's vote, but it seems Worgie has sniffed something out successfully given he's gone straight in with the vote, and will give us his own reasoning once Arlee responds.

*waits patiently*

I am leaning towards believing Worgen unless he is just covering his own ass for something he said to Arlee. If that isn't the case then there would be no reason for a scum (assuming Worgen is scum) to out themselves like this.


Firebert, where are you and your charts at? Who has Robo voted on each day?

[Rigimi44]

Worgen coming in with a vote on Arlee, eh? I too, will wait to see what Arlee says and if Worgen will explain some more. I don't want to needlessly vote this early.

[Dyra]

Oh and I thought of more stuff! It's reasonable to assume the Assassins Club Mafia (or w/e they are called) are definitely responsible for Foxxi's death (given they investigated her and came up with something that might be Cop). Zsasz is an SK, whether stand alone or not is still to be determined. No-one got stabbed the first night right?

As for the third kill, I think it's perfectly reasonable to be assuming a second Mafia team. But what could their specialist be? (Assuming they've got one)

---------- Post added 2013-01-21 at 11:07 PM ----------

*remembers to do the riddle once more since she approves of this one highly*

[Lysah]

This riddle sucks and it should feel sucks.

[listo95]

So we did kill a mafia over night! Now this riddle.... it should feel bad, because it hurts my brain because I barely know anything about the Batman universe (does not help that we did not get the number of letters that are in this word or 2 riddle). But yeah, I'm going to hold my vote back until I see how Arlee defends this.

[falbacca]

Wow what an interesting night - especially with a doctor being part of a Mafia group! I agree listo - I'm not sure what the answer is ... I only know a few things as well when it comes to Batman. Also, I'm also gonna wait to hold any votes until Worg discusses stuff with Arlee.

[Rollo]

I think we originally had 4 possible NKs. The 3 on night 1 would be League Mafia killing The Oracle. Vigilante Masons killing Jack Ryder. Joker/Zsasz/SK scum team killing Mr. Freeze. The Riddler's kill was stopped by the correct response.

We lynched TwoFace (who I'm assuming had a 50% chance on a coin flip kill) so we didn't get that kill last night. League Mafia killed Elvis Jones (who was interviewed the previous night). Dr. Strange conducts the interview while the mafia decide on a kill target. His interview hinted at him being a cop or jailer or something, so maybe that's why they targeted him for a kill. Last night the interview uncovered The Mad Hatter. It would be my belief that the League Mafia has the Hatter's identity now and may target him/her. Maybe Worgen knows something. Someone didn't answer, or answered incorrectly The Riddler's riddle so they died. That leaves Zsasz's kill tonight, but a Joker kill night 1? Maybe we have a second mafia team that includes Zsasz and The Joker. In this setup The Riddler would be the lone SK.

---------- Post added 2013-01-21 at 03:56 PM ----------

FoS Worgenite and Arlee

Worgenite for the above, Arlee because Worgen just might be on to something and wouldn't necessarily give himself up as mafia that easily.

[Decagon]

We could also have a jack that has a NK as well, or perhaps something much like the TwoFace thing (I'm assuming you're correct in assuming they had a 50% chance of being able to kill), but has not gotten a NK because of luck, or perhaps we have several doctors or roleblocks. It's possible we had 4 NKs, but that's not necessarily true and I would guess we had more

[Anakso]

Interviewer sounds like a fun role

Going to wait for Arlee to post but pretty sure I pushed for a worg lynch in a previous game for this exact thing. Do not recall out come. Might have been firebert and not worg. xD

[Lysah]

I could push for a firebert lynch this game. He posted math, after all.

[Arlee]

Meh Worg just voted me because I had told him I was Elvis Jones, but it turned out Greeney had made a mistake on that and while I still have the same role, my character name is different. So basically he saw the end of day and was "ahmg Arlee lied to me lynch her!", like he does. Anywho lynch me if you want, at least you'd only be lynching a vt instead of another tpr.

Interesting that there was apparently a mafia doctor... that's an interesting twist. But hey at least we have one scum down! So that means there is definitely a vigilante? Unless I am confusing something.

[Krayzy]

Meh Worg just voted me because I had told him I was Elvis Jones, but it turned out Greeney had made a mistake on that and while I still have the same role, my character name is different. So basically he saw the end of day and was "ahmg Arlee lied to me lynch her!", like he does. Anywho lynch me if you want, at least you'd only be lynching a vt instead of another tpr.

Interesting that there was apparently a mafia doctor... that's an interesting twist. But hey at least we have one scum down! So that means there is definitely a vigilante? Unless I am confusing something.

If it is true that Greeney messed up and told you that you were the wrong character then he better come in here and tell all of us that.

If he doesn't come in here then my vote is on you. Also, if he doesn't straighten this out and it ends up that this did indeed happen then screw this game.

This game has enough unknowns. We don't need to be adding to it and lynch a townie because of a mod screw up. (Greeney, if this didn't happen then I hope you stay out of this because I would also hate it if you messed up Arlee's strategy of trying to cover her own ass.)

[Arlee]

Eh... I'm not honestly sure if it is really a situation where Greeney should say something. If he does he would be pretty much confirming me as a VT... which, well it just shouldn't happen in a mafia game (excepting of course the innocent child). Honestly I should have just reminded Worgen that in this game the mod asked for people to refrain from pm'ing, but i didn't so in that sense it's my own fault.

[Lysah]

People have to PM, look at twoface.

[Rollo]

Interesting that there was apparently a mafia doctor... that's an interesting twist. But hey at least we have one scum down! So that means there is definitely a vigilante? Unless I am confusing something.

4 NKs on a 30 player game isn't out if this world. I'm just assuming we had a Vigi kill night 1 and no riddler kill and vice versa or night 2.

---------- Post added 2013-01-21 at 06:38 PM ----------

People have to PM, look at twoface.

I think she meant that Greeney wants non teammates to try and refrain from PMing.

[Krayzy]

I completely forgot about that rule (I have only been involved in PM's in a couple of the games I have played). I want to vote against both of you for breaking it (I know he wasn't enforcing it and I know scum (or survivors...whatever the hell those are) would have to PM each other).

/grumpy

Vote Arlee

If you turn up town then Worgen is getting my next vote. If I am still alive.

Either way, can we not take 5 real days to finish this day this time? This game is dragging on and without some personal fighting / arguing and discussion about it we wouldn't have had that many posts outside of the initial "day".