I tank with heroic Jasper Clawfeet, even with the crit (and crit as socket bonus) they were better then the Raid Finder boots I was using before.
---------- Post added 2013-01-21 at 05:20 PM ----------
Method plays on my server, when I inspect there main paladin-tank he usually have that trinket equipped so it doesn't suck. But ofc they have everything on farm so he is probably prioritising his dps even doe it gives a fair amount of damage reduction.
To reiterate Firefly, that is an absolutely abysmal reason for doing something. Prince Charles calls his black friend Sooty, doesn't mean we should go around calling black people that. The Queen refers to herself as "one" - you definitely shouldn't do that one either.
Unfortunately I can't make more of an argument than that with regards to what's better as I never got my hands on those trinkets and I'm unable to play until Easter.
Using http://eu.battle.net/wow/en/item/86042 personally (which took a while to convince my raid that yes it is a damn tank trinket!) as the large amount of haste is on a nice 1 min cd. Will upgrade it if my sha touched doesnt drop this week.
http://www.wowhead.com/item=86042/ja...oteer-figurine
Jade Charioteer Figurine
Item Level 489
Upgrade Level 0/2
Binds when picked up
Unique-Equipped: Jade Charioteer Figurine (1)
Trinket
+1079 Strength
Use: Increases your haste by 3595 for 15 sec. (1 Min Cooldown)
Requires Level 90
Sell Price: 25 39 83
not sure why the wow database is borked