I dont say they are Penalized by certain Groups who look at some honor Lists/rankings/whatever and decide they dont want him.
I say apparently judging by the Attitude of many here, and the Quotes of the OP that these people are activly Harrassed.
I mean did you read some of those Responses? Some (Most of the People in this Thread) People who come from these Groups/Organisations think themselves as people who dictate the Server Law.
And I repeat myself: What I think is messed up is less that you "Decide who you take into your Group, but that these Organisations try to control all PVP on the server. Thats what I think is Messed up.
And as some people pointed out, with (at least how I understand this works) its a form of WinTrading, as the group decides who gets which rank next.
I just stated my Opinion on the whole system. I really really feel it way overboard, and defeating the Point of the entire PVP system.
Sure, probably if you play the system everyone (Except people not in the Cartel) wins. But as I said, I´m a simple guy:
I Log on, I play, I have fun. I think its messed up that someone could come up to me and say: "Hey, you killed to much Horde Scum, you need to stop, or well make you Transfer server" (A Bit exaggerated, but that was kinda what was said in the OP)
Its something I came across in a couple of games, where you play and mind your Business, and then you realize that basically everything is run by this one Organisation. I´m not a big fan of that to be Honest.
This is what I´ve been actually wondering, how in the world can a single person actually make a blip to these groups.
That reinforces my impression that there is actually really a shady cartel like organisation that Bullys/Harasses people, if a single person playing solo can mess up their schedule. If they can keep it that low.
To be fair thats the same amount of Awesome, as its Messed up.