Is this a fucking joke?
So do you mean the predicament of say latinos and blacks in this country aren't based on history? You mean the arguments given in 1800s that foresaw issues we have to this very day don't exist?
Do you mean to tell me when Brutus warned that our current voting system with ostracise the yeoman and common man, and that congress would mostly be made up of those with means to run, thereby creating a sort of aristocracy based on what happen prior to the 1700s that somehow he, despite being right is wrong because in your right wing mind history doesn't determine the future?
Tell me how do you get to a future, do you mean to sit here and explain to us how you get to say.. point C from B if it is just like going from point A to B. You would have us ignore how we got to B from A and say "eh just wing it"????
How about language, you are aware that every language, save one anomaly is recursive. How do we speak if we are to ignore history? Well we know, you have to rebuild and build and repeat and repeat and repeat over and over like they do in that one language I can't recall the name of right now.
What you said said here, is the epitome of "I don't give a fuck about history history doesn't matter"
For your folly statement to make sense, explain to us how we got to where we are today that has no relation to where we were in the past.
Fucking... what the fuck... are you even thinking at this point????????
There has to be a complete absence of thought to say the future doesn't depend on history. Are you like a fucking Boltzmann brain? Is this a bloody Boltzmann brain universe or some shit? Because if not, you've no way to defend that statement.
Last edited by Themius; 2020-07-07 at 08:15 PM.
-literally every political faction does this, it's only partisan bufoons who don't notice it when thier guys do it.
-free market capitalism working as intended!
-uh oh, better watch out for those gun grabbing boogiemen!
-I take it you have no idea what the outcomes of affirmative action even are outside of the handful of instances that fit your argument.
-more boogiemen!
-free market capitalism working as inteded, again!
-I see, you interchange "liberals" and "lefties" as if theyre the same thing, explains a lot.
-racist dog whistle
-same racist dog whistle but somehow humans can hear it.
He's never heard of science in general... or politics.... I mean our current system has roots that goes back well over a thousand years but oh no no that history had no bearing on today.
Fuck remember the declaration of rights of man done about 100 years before American independence? Remember how the founders often were using arguments and quotes from that in their own independence?
Well in PC2 world that didn't happen, and the declaration of independence was not influenced by history which helped determine the future, because clearly.. the future isn't based on history. There are no actions that must happen before a thing happens apparently in PC2 universe.
In PC2 universe things just appear already done up nicely without needing that messy business of being built through time.
Or perhaps he speaks of another dimension where time exist in some sort of persistent state of past present future and therefore history doesn't matter because history is now and later?
In the real world there's this thing called profit and human nature that drive corporate decisions. The goal of short term profit will always override everything especially if it doesn't affect you directly.
Let me ask you this if your theory is correct why has Trump's deregulation led to more pollution when states don't stop him?
1. So you support the right because they are only infringing on other people's lifestyles.
2. Why not fix it with that whole "all are created equal" thing.2. One bad is not fixed with another bad.
3. Less guns means less guns for "bad people" too3. Not when bad people have easy access to plenty of guns.
See nr.24. See nr.2.
Like framing the Civil War to be about "States Rights" instead of Slavery. When the "State Rights" you are fighting for are the right to keep slaves...you are fighting for slavery.5. I have no idea you're talking about.
Removing statues does not re-write or erase history. And don't worry... nobody is going to "forget" Slavery and the Civil War.6. I'm not defending slavery but it does have its point in history, a history that should not be forgotten because triggered idiots erased it.
Corporation worship is an American thing.7. Corporation worshiping is the new thing for the Left, especially if the said corporations happen to be located in California. As an example, how many are protesting against Nike, when it's KNOWN that Nike is using slave labor in China and Africa, but because Nike was smart enough to use that Kaepernick individual who hates America and white people, to do the virtue signaling for them, they avoided the wrath of the Left and BLM.
No the future of latinos and blacks is not based on history whatsoever, unless you specifically want to keep them in the exact same historical trend. Which wouldn't surprise me that you(@Themius) don't want them to improve and you want them to be in the same situation forever.
No, "history matters" for explanations but not for predictions of the future. Those are entirely separate ways of understanding the world.
No, right wingers push for censorship of video games and comic books because they're a moral outrage (see: alien sideboob) or responsible for causing gun violence (see: virtually every school shooting).
Acting like loony fringe ideas are mainstream is the road to nonsense.
On deregulations, did you know trump rolled back Title IX so schools aren't required to investigate rapes, unless the student makes official reports. So even if the faculty know, if a traumatised student doesn't report it fast enough apparently Trump's administration is fine with having rapists on campus. Oh and then they went on to make it even more narrow in general from simply being unwanted sexual misconduct to, unwanted sexual misconduct that denies the person equal access to the school activities and education . what the fuck does this mean?!
It sounds like if a person gets raped, but is able to still go to class and try to live that well they haven't been raped in Trump's Administration eyes.
- - - Updated - - -
So you mean freeing slaves didn't lead to black Americans being free?
You see if we were in the 1860s, and I said okay slaves are being freed, and in the future they will be free.. which will allow them to do certain things.
You would say, in 1930s, the the predicament of black people is not tied to history, laws passed in the past, and freedom of slaves?
You're being illogical.History indeed predicts the future... history is simply data and data will predict what can or will be likely in the future. Do you have a college degree? If so what field? Because this utter lack of critical thinking is hurting me, and critical thinking is a basic skill that should be taught in university.
- - - Updated - - -
right wingers do push for censorship when they are faced with a non-straight person, or a woman protagonist, or a POC protagonist.
I'm not blaming Trump for the pandemic but his inability to be an effective leader and tackle these protests/riots while addressing the virus as it is has been costly.
The left control all but one of the major news networks, all but two or three major newspapers, they control college campuses (which they have let seep into the broader culture), they control the entertainment industry to push their messaging, they control social media and tech websites, etc. etc. etc. Meanwhile the right puts all of our effort into winning congressional races in Iowa. We are doomed.
You think CNN is left? You think MSNBC is left?
Both moved further right, especially CNN after Trump was elected with many of their commentators being people who have been conservative for decades.
Because your side has moved from conservative, to fascist, doesn't mean all conservatives are now left.
Please tell us more of this conspiracy theory and how the left are dooming you... meanwhile. I rather not be randomly shot because of how I look because some random maga supporter decides I need to go back where I came from.
Far Right Trumpers. Biggest snowflakes of them all. Better look under your bed and in your closets, the far left boogeymen might be there!
The majority of news networks are controlled by right wingers. Those right wingers might pander to the left wing occasionally but their money is spent on perpetuating right wing causes. Messaging is one thing but the real work is lobbying and that's how the right perpetuates itself.
This is entirely wrong, history is not 'data' that can ever determine the "probability" of the future. Information and data can help change people's 'theory' such as whether or not black Americans are people and deserve equal opportunity but it's not about predicting the future. The very fact that slaves were freed is a short proof of the fact that historical trends do not determine the future and if people truly believed that there would be no progress whatsoever.
Last edited by PC2; 2020-07-08 at 01:39 AM.