Originally Posted by
Endus
I've yet to see any real evidence that the "average" rank is being dragged downwards over time, and that's really the only actual evidence of an issue in their ranking system that there could be. If the average is sticking around the same value (Whatever that may be; Overbuff.com and Masteroverwatch.com both have limited samples so I'm not sure how accurate their stats are), then the ranking system is working fine; individuals moving up or down are moving around as expected.
A lot of this is bias (and I don't mean that as a slur); people only see what they see, and often don't notice their own mistakes that other people spot. See that guy who just ignores the Reaper who jumps down and shoots him in the back? Frustrated that he's so blind? He legitimately didn't see him. The next time around, it's gonna be you cursing that Reaper for appearing out of nowhere. This isn't your teammates being worse than you, it's you blaming them for their failures, but thinking your own failures are because the game is "unfair".
The better way to go in is to presume that EVERY time you die, it's because YOU fucked up. If you're a tank and you died because you had no heals, WHY didn't you have heals? Did you Charge in when your healers were dead? Was Mercy not dumb enough to follow you into the entire enemy team when everyone else on your team is dead? These are your errors, even if you didn't notice them in the heat of the moment.
I've been on both sides of that, in the same rank range. Sometimes, I'm the Soldier who's killing their entire back team in a single ult because I flanked and they didn't notice. Sometimes, I'm the Zenyatta who gets slaughtered by the same tactic.
Also, don't get stuck "maining" heroes. Rein's useful at times, especially with certain offense heroes (Soldier 76 particularly IMO), but he's not the tank you "need" in every match. Same for healers; I actually think Mercy's significantly overrated, even after her most recent buff. She's either healing OR dealing damage. So while her heals ARE decently strong, Zenyatta's are weaker BUT he A> has respectable offensive power in his own right that doesn't require sacrificing his healing, and 2> has a MUCH better buff than Mercy's; Discord Orb boosts EVERYONE's damage against the target, not one hero's. The only case where Mercy's really outshines Zenyatta's is in buffing someone during their ultimate, which is pretty niche.
Sure, rez is nice, but I've won plenty of games with Zen's ultimate, where Mercy's rez would've gotten us killed or never been useful. Zarya just snagged half the team with her black hole? Pop Zen's ultimate, and you'll probably all survive, where with Mercy, you'd be one of the first to die and never get a chance to rez anyone. Your team's losing the point, and your team's almost back but won't make it? Pop Zen's ult and dance on the point while invincible, to buy time. Etc.
The rez is good, but it's not that great. Especially not when it lets everyone see where the rezzed participants are. You're basically hoping the team gets nuked by their combo-ults AND Mercy escapes, so she can rez and you can return the favor, and that's risky. It LOOKS good when you can pull it off, but I find Transcendance more consistently useful.
I mean, if you LIKE Mercy, by all means, I'm not saying she's bad. I'm just arguing against the mindset some people have that "these heroes have to be in any competitive match". You can kind of make that case with Lucio, since he's the only AoE healer (which is an issue), but everyone else is VERY much up to player preference, within comp expectations. The latest tier list by Overbuff that I'm aware of has nobody at the high-competitive level in the S or A tiers, at all; there's some preference to certain heroes, but no "OMG always pick this guy" ones.