Originally Posted by
M-Ra
They are kinda no more since Wotlk. They had a good last stand in the DK Starting Area and the Scarlet Onslaught was just a bad Joke and everything after the DK Starting Area was just beating a dead Horse, just like Blizzard wanted to bully the Scarlet Crusade Fans on the world. Back in Classic they were a interesting Faction. Lawful Evil Paladins, which was kinda unique, I think their motives and actions were really understandable, albeit evil, and I liked their "The end justifies the means"-approach.
They were protrayed interesting in the Corebooks, which were Canon until the statement that they are not and had really, really cool Prestige Classes. The Scarlet Inquisitor and the Scarlet Crusader were pretty badass and the Scarlet Battlemage was far more than just badass. The NPCs of the Scarlet Crusade in Light's Hope Chapel were pretty cool and far more awesome that those Argent Dawn Guys, ecept the Brotherhood of the Light. They had a good Background, a noble History and were a really interesting Faction back in the old World (which remidns me that the Villain Factions were far more interesting than todays in general.
The Shadow Council with it's many cults were really mysterious, the Twilight's Hammer was far more interesting and mysterious back then, the Defias had a really good Background, the Syndicate, the Bloodsail Buccaneers...especially in the Corebooks, the World of Warcraft was never again that much deep and interesting). I am surprised that there are no Scarlet Crusade Fans in the english community. In the german RP Community, some of the biggest RP guilds had the Scarlet Crusade theme, there were many Scarlet Crusade guilds until Cataclysm and the whole concept was far more popular than Argent Dawn or Argent Crusade.
Until today, there were never a really big and successful Argent themed guild and even with the Scarlet Crusade dead and deceased, the Brotherhood of Light seems to be far more popular than the actual Argent Crusade. Many People I knew don't really liked Tirion Fordring and feel more sympathy towards the Scarlet Crusade and even the one Tirion Fan I know liked him because of his Classic Quest Chain and his novel, not because of Wotlk.