Hypotetically:
- I have a list of items picked up in order. Because that matches the Bomber Star + Graeham PoW block on D2.
- Crackle picked up the red shell on D2 for post #875.
- Crackle is evil scum, and used that red shell on someone last gameday.
- I am not at all sure whom, as I am not told of item use at day time. Let's call the target player X.
- Crackle does not want to be caught for that use, so he claims he has been holding a green shell for a long time.
- But in reality he picked up the green shell after using the red one.
So that was the theory. Then you come along and throw some serious sand into that theory.
Per #1148, you claim to have picked up the red shell on D2. And you visibly lost it to Bombecloner's banana in #839 (recorded in #842). This is were things get messy, right?
- I most certainly cannot refute you picked up a red shell. That is evident as day.
- I am not convinced you picked it up on D2. There is a red shell left-over from D1. Maybe that was what you lost?!
- It is hypothetically possible you are covering for Crackleslap here.
But lets look at that realistically. I am looking for a crime where the victim is not confirmed, and assuming a culprit based on a swapped murder weapon theory. That's a stretch. Furthermore... I can prove you used an item on D2, you threw a banana at Catta in #730. Meaning unless you can hold TWO items, the theory of you holding a red shell from D1 is dead as a doornail.
So let's just bury this theory once and for all.
--
But that detour was not all waste.
Reading back on D2 I am reminded of an earlier theory I had.
If Catta is scum, now confirmed, why a modkill murder attempt on Bombercloner, a player who hadn't played in a long time, when Monkz was just as good a target by that D1? Even if Monkz was lynched early last game... there is something there, maybe.
@Monkz; I would like to know more about you. What is your take on the game at this point?
- - - Updated - - -
You can read my D1 reads of you in my QT post-game. It's not pretty. Stuff like "Scumreading [of dupti] intensifies. Dupti pressuring me to claim TPR. "
You opening with the post on Catta very much torpedoed my mistrust of you. Well, it's not 100% gone as you can see. But yeah.
That is something I very much appreciate knowing.Welp I need to go again, but Danner I think there is a pretty high chance Crackle is scum.
My biggest issue with Crackle is his opening post of this day.
I just cannot get that to fit, unless he was angry with me for something.